Executive Summary

Nam Cheong is a Malaysian offshore support vessel (OSV) provider listed on SGX, operating the largest and youngest fleet in Malaysian waters (38 vessels, average age 8 years). The company emerged from a dramatic debt restructuring in March 2024, converting RM674M of liabilities into equity and cash, reducing borrowings from RM1,044M to RM458M. Revenue has grown at a 17% CAGR from FY2020-FY2024, driven entirely by vessel chartering (shipbuilding dormant), with gross margins expanding from 18.7% to 53.1% as charter rates surged. The founder-chairman Tan Sri Datuk Tiong Su Kouk controls ~32% of shares directly and through related entities, personally injecting SGD 8.75M during the restructuring. At SGD 1.30, the stock trades at ~6x TTM P/E (heavily distorted by one-off gains) and ~8-10x normalized earnings. However, this is a deeply cyclical oil services business with concentrated customer risk (63% from top 3 customers, all Malaysia), heavy debt (RM458M), no dividends, and sensitivity to oil price cycles. The recent 225% price surge from post-restructuring levels has priced in much of the recovery. WAIT for pullback.

Investment Thesis (3 sentences): Nam Cheong owns a young, well-positioned OSV fleet benefiting from structural supply tightness and Petronas's E&P capex ramp, generating 50%+ gross margins in a sweet spot of the OSV cycle. The company's debt restructuring cleared RM674M of liabilities and restored positive equity, but RM458M of borrowings remain with a 7-year repayment schedule, and 9M2025 results show revenue declining 12% with fleet utilization falling to 70%. At SGD 1.30 (8-10x normalized P/E), the market has largely priced in the recovery; accumulate at SGD 0.85 for a genuine margin of safety.

---

PHASE 0: Opportunity Identification (Klarman)

Why Does This Opportunity Exist?

1. Post-restructuring re-rating: The company emerged from a 6-year restructuring process in March 2024, with trading resuming on SGX. Many institutional investors cannot hold stocks that were suspended or restructured, creating a temporary dislocation.
2. Turnaround complexity: The balance sheet went from negative equity of RM625M (FY2022) to positive equity of RM575M (FY2024), but understanding the true economics requires stripping out RM399M of one-off debt waiver gains and RM74M of inventory write-down reversals.
3. Small-cap, niche market: SGD 518M market cap in the offshore support vessel space, covered by virtually no international analysts. Only DBS Research has initiated coverage.
4. Creditor overhang: 176M shares were issued to creditors as part of the restructuring. As creditors sell down, this creates temporary selling pressure and depressed pricing.
5. Oil price uncertainty: Brent crude averaging ~$75-80/bbl provides solid OSV demand, but OPEC+ uncertainty and energy transition narratives create a sentiment discount for all O&G services companies.

Assessment: The opportunity is real but diminishing. The stock has already re-rated 225% from post-restructuring levels. The remaining upside depends on sustained charter rate strength and successful debt paydown, both of which are uncertain in a cyclical industry.

---

PHASE 1: Risk Analysis (Inversion Thinking)

1. Oil Price Collapse (P=20%, Impact: -60%)

An oil price decline to $50-60/bbl would cause Petronas and other national oil companies to cut E&P capex aggressively. OSV demand would fall sharply, charter rates would crater, and fleet utilization could drop below 50%. Nam Cheong experienced this in 2015-2020 when revenue fell 80% and the company went into negative equity. This is the existential risk. Expected Loss: 12.0%

2. Customer Concentration / Petronas Dependency (P=25%, Impact: -35%)

63% of revenue comes from 3 customers. 100% of revenue is from Malaysia. If Petronas cuts its OSV requirements or shifts to different providers, Nam Cheong has limited diversification. The company is expanding into the Middle East (5 vessels) but this is nascent. Expected Loss: 8.8%

3. Debt Refinancing / Liquidity Risk (P=15%, Impact: -50%)

RM458M of borrowings remain, with RM35M due within one year but RM423M due over 2-7 years. Interest rates of 3.0-7.3% on term loans are manageable now, but if charter rates decline, the company's ability to service and repay debt could be strained. Cash was RM128M at FY2024 end. The company generates RM191M operating cash flow but has significant capex needs (RM98M in FY2024). Expected Loss: 7.5%

4. Fleet Age / Capex Cycle Risk (P=30%, Impact: -25%)

While the current fleet averages 8 years (young), vessels require increasing maintenance over time and eventually need replacement. Capital expenditure of RM98M in FY2024 was largely for vessel acquisitions. As the fleet ages, maintenance capex will rise, potentially squeezing free cash flow. The shipbuilding division is dormant -- restarting it would require significant investment. Expected Loss: 7.5%

5. OSV Market Cycle Peak (P=35%, Impact: -30%)

The OSV market has been in a strong upcycle since 2022. Industry data suggests floater rig activity may bottom in 2026-2027, and FPSO installations peak in 2025 then decline. If the market is near-peak, charter rates could stagnate or decline from current elevated levels. 9M2025 already shows utilization falling from 86% to 70%. Expected Loss: 10.5%

6. Family Control / Corporate Governance Risk (P=15%, Impact: -30%)

The Tiong family controls ~32% of shares. The Chairman is 83 years old. Two sons are in senior management (Executive Vice Chairman and Executive Director Operations). Related party transactions exist through CCK Group. Board independence has improved (3 of 5 directors are independent, all appointed April 2024), but family-controlled Asian companies carry governance discount. Expected Loss: 4.5%

7. Currency Risk (P=20%, Impact: -15%)

Revenue is in RM but the stock is SGD-denominated. RM weakness versus SGD would reduce the SGD value of earnings. Additionally, USD exposure exists through USD-denominated borrowings (RM83M) and SGD borrowings (RM253M). Expected Loss: 3.0%

Total Risk-Weighted Expected Loss: ~53.8%

Inversion Section

How could this lose 50%+ permanently?

• Oil price collapse to $50/bbl sustained for 2+ years, crushing charter rates and utilization
• Petronas cuts OSV requirements due to gas-focused pivot or fiscal austerity
• Debt cannot be serviced if cash flow deteriorates, leading to second restructuring
• All three combined: a repeat of the 2015-2020 near-death experience

If I were short, my 3-sentence bear case: Nam Cheong is a deeply cyclical oil services company that nearly went bankrupt, survived only through massive debt forgiveness, and is now riding a cyclical upswing that is already showing signs of peaking (9M2025 utilization down to 70%). The company has zero diversification -- 100% Malaysia revenue, 63% customer concentration, and dormant shipbuilding -- with RM458M of debt and no dividend track record. The stock has already tripled from restructuring lows, pricing in a recovery that may be near its peak.

Can I state the bear case better than the bears? Yes. The cyclicality risk is the fundamental issue. This business nearly died in the last downturn and carries significant structural leverage (operating and financial) that amplifies both upside and downside.

---

PHASE 2: Financial Analysis

Revenue Analysis

Revenue has grown from a cyclical trough, driven by three factors: (1) fleet expansion from ~28 to 37 vessels, (2) improved daily charter rates (Malaysian OSV market rates up ~40-60% from 2021 lows), and (3) higher utilization of larger vessels.

Revenue per vessel (approximate): RM18.5M/vessel (FY2024) vs RM17.0M (FY2023), indicating both fleet growth and rate improvement driving top line.

9M2025 concern: Revenue is down 12% YoY. Fleet utilization dropped from 86% (3Q2024) to 70% (3Q2025). This could be temporary (vessel repositioning for Middle East deployment) or could signal cycle moderation.

Profitability Analysis

The gross margin expansion from 18.7% to 53.1% is remarkable and reflects the operating leverage inherent in vessel chartering -- fixed costs (depreciation, crew) are spread over higher revenue as rates and utilization improve.

Key cost breakdown (FY2024, from Note 22):

• Crew costs: RM115.3M (36% of COGS)
• Engine and deck stores: RM52.7M (16%)
• Charter fees: RM54.2M (17%) -- costs of sub-chartering vessels
• Ship repair costs: RM9.5M (3%)
• Insurance: RM12.5M (4%)
• Depreciation: RM37.6M (12%)

Normalized Earnings (Stripping One-Offs)

FY2024 reported net profit of RM800.2M is meaningless for valuation. Let me normalize:

However, this still includes the full-year benefit of peak charter rates. Using 9M2025 core profit of RM133.7M annualized (~RM178M) as a more conservative run-rate gives a more realistic picture of sustainable earnings.

Normalized EPS range: RM0.45-0.66 per share (RM178M-260M / 393M shares) In SGD: ~SGD 0.12-0.17 per share (at RM/SGD 3.8) P/E on normalized earnings: ~7.6-10.8x

Balance Sheet Health

The balance sheet transformation is dramatic. The restructuring eliminated RM586M of debt (56% reduction) and restored positive equity. However, RM458M of remaining debt is significant relative to a RM575M equity base.

Debt maturity profile:

• Year 1: RM35M (manageable)
• Year 2: RM78M
• Year 3-5: RM163M
• 5+ years: RM182M

The 7-year repayment schedule is manageable if charter rates hold, but becomes challenging in a downturn.

Cash Flow Analysis

FY2024 was the first year of meaningful positive FCF generation. The company needs to use this to deleverage. At RM55M/year of surplus cash after capex and debt service, it would take ~6 years to fully repay the remaining RM458M -- broadly consistent with the 7-year plan.

Owner Earnings Calculation

Valuation

DCF Valuation (10-year, 2-stage model):

Assumptions:

• Base FCF: RM100M (conservative, below FY2024 peak)
• Years 1-5 growth: 5% (moderate fleet expansion + rate stabilization)
• Years 6-10 growth: 2% (mature, cyclical)
• Terminal growth: 1% (cyclical industry, minimal real growth)
• Discount rate: 14% (high for cyclical, leveraged, small-cap, governance)

Wait -- this DCF implies the current SGD 1.30 price is significantly overvalued vs my RM-based DCF of RM1.53/share. Let me check the conversion. The market cap is SGD 518M = RM 1,969M at RM/SGD 3.8. Total shares outstanding are 393M (for RM basis), but the SGD market cap implies the market is valuing equity at RM 1,969M -- far above my DCF of RM 599M.

Let me reconsider. There's a discrepancy in share counts. The AR2024 shows 392.25M shares. At SGD 1.30, market cap = SGD 510M. At RM/SGD 3.8, that's RM 1,938M. My DCF gives RM 599M equity value, implying fair value of SGD 0.40 -- the stock appears massively overvalued on conservative DCF.

However, my FCF base of RM100M may be too conservative. FY2024 operating cash flow was RM191M. If I use RM150M as normalized FCF:

Revised DCF with RM150M base FCF: equity value ~RM900M = SGD 0.60/share. Still well below SGD 1.30.

Using RM200M base FCF (optimistic): equity value ~RM1,200M = SGD 0.80/share. Still below market.

The market is pricing in either (a) significantly higher FCF than current levels, (b) a lower discount rate, or (c) fleet value above book value.

Asset-based valuation (cross-check):

• PPE (vessels + yard): RM712M book value
• Average vessel age: 8 years vs 25-year life
• Replacement cost of 38 vessels: RM1.5-2.0B (estimated at $10-15M each)
• Net assets: RM575M
• P/B: 1.30 * 393M / (575M/3.8) = SGD510M / SGD151M = 3.4x book value

At 3.4x book value for an asset-heavy, cyclical business with recent restructuring, the stock looks expensive on traditional value metrics.

Relative valuation:

Nam Cheong trades at a significant premium to peers on P/B. The P/E depends heavily on normalization assumptions.

---

PHASE 3: Moat Analysis

Moat Sources Assessment

1. Petronas License / Regulatory Barrier (NARROW)

• Nam Cheong holds a valid Petronas license, required for all OSV operators in Malaysian waters
• Malaysia's cabotage policy (Merchant Shipping Ordinance) protects local vessel operators
• This provides a moderate barrier but is not exclusive -- multiple Malaysian operators hold licenses

2. Fleet Scale & Youth (NARROW)

• 38 vessels averaging 8 years old vs industry average of 15-16 years
• Largest OSV fleet in Malaysian waters
• Younger fleet = lower maintenance costs, higher uptime, client preference
• However, competitors can acquire/build vessels to close the gap

3. Customer Relationships (NARROW)

• Long-term relationships with Petronas and international oil majors
• Multi-year charter contracts secured for ~60% of fleet
• RM400M of secured long-term charter revenue provides visibility
• But contracts are renegotiated and customers can switch

4. Shipbuilding Integration (POTENTIAL)

• Owns 12.6-hectare Miri shipyard (currently dormant)
• Capability to build new OSVs at lower cost than buying from third parties
• Can time newbuilds to market cycles
• Not currently active, so not generating moat value today

Moat Rating: NARROW

The moat is narrow and entirely dependent on the Malaysian cabotage/Petronas licensing regime and fleet scale advantages. There are no network effects, no switching costs beyond contract terms, no brand premium, and no cost advantage that competitors cannot replicate. The moat is regulatory and scale-based, both of which can erode.

Durability: 5-10 years, contingent on Malaysian O&G policy continuity Trend: Stable to narrowing (Middle East expansion is a positive signal, but domestic moat unchanged)

---

PHASE 4: Decision Synthesis

Management Assessment

CEO: Leong Seng Keat (since May 2013) -- 20+ years with the Group, built the chartering division from scratch, navigated the restructuring period. Operationally proven.

Chairman: Tan Sri Datuk Tiong Su Kouk (age 83) -- Founder, 27.2% direct ownership, personally invested SGD 8.75M during 2024 restructuring. Genuine skin in the game.

Key concern: Family control (Chairman's sons in VP and operations roles), succession risk (Chairman is 83), and potential for related-party transactions with CCK Group.

Capital allocation: No dividends to ordinary shareholders since listing (RM8.2M paid to NCI only). Focus is on debt repayment and fleet expansion. This is appropriate given the debt level but leaves shareholders without return of capital.

Position Sizing Framework

Given the risk profile (cyclical, leveraged, single-market, post-restructuring), this would warrant a maximum 2-3% portfolio allocation even at attractive prices.

At current prices (SGD 1.30), the risk-reward is insufficient for any position:

• Downside: 50-60% in a severe oil downturn
• Upside: 30-50% if cycle extends and debt paydown accelerates
• Asymmetry: Unfavorable at current price

Decision Matrix

Monitoring Triggers

---

Final Verdict

WAIT -- Do Not Buy at SGD 1.30

Nam Cheong is a competently managed, well-positioned OSV operator benefiting from structural supply tightness in the Malaysian offshore market. The debt restructuring was transformative, and the founder-chairman's personal investment demonstrates genuine commitment. However:

1. Valuation is stretched: At SGD 1.30, the stock trades at 3.4x book value and 8-10x normalized earnings for a deeply cyclical, leveraged, single-market business. DCF analysis suggests fair value of SGD 0.60-0.80.

2. Cycle risk is rising: 9M2025 shows utilization declining (70% vs 86%), revenue down 12% YoY, and global OSV market analysts flagging a potential 2026-2027 slowdown. The best time to buy cyclicals is at the bottom, not near the top.

3. Insufficient margin of safety: The business has demonstrated its vulnerability -- it nearly went bankrupt in 2015-2020 with equity going to negative RM771M. The current recovery, while real, does not justify paying premium multiples.

4. No dividends, no buybacks: Shareholders receive zero capital return. All cash goes to debt service and fleet expansion. This is appropriate but means returns depend entirely on capital appreciation.

Entry Prices

Current gap to accumulate: SGD 1.30 vs SGD 0.85 = 35% above entry price.

---

Analysis based on: Annual Reports 2020-2024 (downloaded from namcheong.com.my), SGX filings, StockAnalysis.com financial data, NextInsight.net management commentary, Spinergie OSV market research.