Back to Portfolio
AXP

American Express

$352.17 243B market cap February 1, 2026
American Express Company AXP BUFFETT / MUNGER / KLARMAN SUMMARY
1 SNAPSHOT
Price$352.17
Market Cap243B
2 BUSINESS

American Express is a rare Buffett-owned financial compounder with a closed-loop payment network that provides complete customer data ownership, enabling superior personalization and engagement. The premium brand positioning attracts affluent cardholders who spend 3x more than average, justifying the higher merchant discount rate. With ROE consistently above 30%, Millennial/Gen-Z adoption accelerating (now 36% of spend), and international expansion creating decades of runway, AmEx is a generational compounder. However, at 23x earnings after a 192% 5-year gain, the stock offers no margin of safety. Wait for a 10-15% pullback to accumulate. This is Buffett's longest-held financial for a reason - own it, but at the right price.

3 MOAT WIDE

Closed-loop payment network, 175-year brand heritage, Centurion Lounges, 160M merchant relationships, premium customer lock-in via Membership Rewards

4 MANAGEMENT
CEO: Stephen Squeri

Excellent - 17% share count reduction since 2019, doubled dividend, disciplined CapEx

5 ECONOMICS
20.6% Op Margin
18.5% ROIC
32.2% ROE
22.88x P/E
12.14B FCF
796% Debt/EBITDA
6 VALUATION
FCF Yield5%
DCF Range280 - 320

Overvalued by 15-25%

7 MUNGER INVERSION
Kill Event Severity P() E[Loss]
Economic recession could impact discretionary spending and credit quality HIGH - -
Merchant pushback on premium MDR (2.3-2.8% vs. V/MA 1.5-2.0%) MED - -
8 KLARMAN LENS
Downside Case

Economic recession could impact discretionary spending and credit quality

Why Market Right

Recession-driven credit deterioration; Merchant defections if MDR pressure intensifies; Regulatory expansion of Durbin Amendment to credit cards

Catalysts

Platinum Card refresh driving 2x acquisition levels; Millennial/Gen-Z now 36% of spend, transactions 25% higher than older cohorts; International revenue accelerating (13-15% FX-adjusted growth); Market correction creating entry opportunity

9 VERDICT WAIT
A Quality Strong - CET1 10.5%, lowest stress capital buffer (2.5%), Fed confirmed best-in-class credit risk
Strong Buy$280
Buy$315
Fair Value$320

Set price alerts at $315 (Accumulate) and $280 (Strong Buy). Do not chase current levels.

🧠 ULTRATHINK Deep Philosophical Analysis

American Express: An Ultrathink Meditation

A Deep Philosophical Analysis in the Buffett/Munger/Klarman Tradition

The Core Question: What Makes This Business Special?

American Express forces the value investor to confront a fundamental question: Can a 175-year-old company still possess a widening moat?

The answer lies not in the age of the business, but in the nature of its competitive advantage. AmEx's moat is not a static wall but a living organism - fed by network effects that strengthen with each transaction, each new merchant relationship, each premium cardholder who chooses Platinum over Chase Sapphire.

Consider the mathematics of the closed-loop network: When AmEx signs a new merchant, that merchant gains access to cardholders who spend 3x the industry average. When a new cardholder joins, they gain access to 160 million merchants globally plus exclusive benefits at 27,000 Resy restaurants, 30+ Centurion Lounges, and 2,600 premium hotels. Each addition to either side of this two-sided marketplace makes the other side more valuable.

This is the essence of what Buffett calls a "franchise" - a business whose value to customers increases even as it raises prices. AmEx has increased the Platinum annual fee from $450 to $695 over the past decade while retention remained above 98%. Only businesses with true pricing power can achieve this paradox.

Moat Meditation: The Durability of Premium Positioning

Munger teaches us to invert: Instead of asking "Why will AmEx succeed?", ask "What could destroy this business?"

Scenario 1: A Merchant Revolt Merchants have complained about AmEx's premium MDR (2.3-2.8% vs. Visa/Mastercard's 1.5-2.0%) for decades. Yet acceptance has quintupled since 2017. Why? Because the math works. A restaurant that accepts AmEx sees higher ticket sizes and repeat visits from affluent diners. The 0.8% premium pays for itself. Costco's famous AmEx defection in 2016 remains the exception that proves the rule - and notably, Costco's credit card business struggled for years afterward.

Scenario 2: Competitive Erosion Chase Sapphire, Capital One Venture, and others have attacked the premium space aggressively. Yet AmEx's share of new premium card issuance has held steady or grown. Why? Brand heritage cannot be manufactured. You cannot "out-Centurion" Centurion. The psychological value of the AmEx brand - the status signal, the trust earned over 175 years, the institutional memory of customer service excellence - is accumulated capital that competitors cannot replicate in a decade or even a generation.

Scenario 3: Technological Disruption Apple Pay, Google Pay, Buy Now Pay Later, cryptocurrency - the payments landscape evolves constantly. Yet AmEx has adapted to every shift. Their cards work seamlessly with digital wallets. Their app is consistently rated among the best in financial services. The company spends billions annually on technology. More importantly, AmEx owns what matters: the customer relationship. Whether you tap a plastic card, wave your phone, or use a QR code, AmEx still earns the discount revenue if they own the underlying account.

Scenario 4: Credit Crisis This is the real risk. AmEx carries credit risk that Visa and Mastercard do not. A severe recession could spike write-offs and force reserve builds. Yet the company demonstrated remarkable resilience during COVID, when consumer credit broadly deteriorated but AmEx's premium customer base continued paying their bills. The Fed's stress tests consistently show AmEx with the lowest projected credit card loss rate among all banks subject to CCAR. The affluent don't stop paying their bills because the stock market drops.

The honest conclusion: None of these scenarios pose existential threats. The moat is not merely wide but likely widening.

The Owner's Mindset: Would Buffett Own This for 20 Years?

He has owned it for 30.

This is not hyperbole - Buffett first invested in American Express during the Salad Oil Scandal of 1963, when the company's stock collapsed amid fears of bankruptcy. He recognized then what remains true today: AmEx's competitive position does not depend on any single manager, product, or technology. It depends on an accumulated base of customer trust and merchant relationships that would take any competitor decades to replicate.

Buffett's partnership letter from 1964 is instructive: "American Express is an outstanding company with wonderful profit margins, a valuable trademark, and a commanding position in a very fast-growing field." Sixty-two years later, every word still applies.

The question for today's investor is not whether AmEx is a wonderful business - it clearly is - but whether today's price offers adequate compensation for the capital deployed.

Risk Inversion: What Could Make Me Wrong?

Klarman's margin of safety principle demands we imagine ways our thesis could fail:

  1. The Premium Card Category Commoditizes

    • Counter-evidence: Fee-based premium cards are the fastest-growing segment
    • Counter-evidence: AmEx's card fee revenue has doubled since 2019
    • Assessment: Low probability

  2. Millennial/Gen-Z Adoption Reverses

    • Counter-evidence: 36% of spend now from these cohorts
    • Counter-evidence: Transaction frequency 25% higher than older cohorts
    • Assessment: Low probability - momentum accelerating

  3. Management Deteriorates Post-Squeri

    • Counter-evidence: Deep bench, company promotes from within
    • Counter-evidence: Institutional culture of excellence
    • Assessment: Moderate probability but manageable - the franchise transcends individuals

  4. Regulatory Intervention

    • Durbin Amendment expansion to credit cards
    • Antitrust action on closed-loop model
    • Counter-evidence: Closed-loop networks have historically been exempt
    • Assessment: Low probability but unpredictable

  5. Valuation Multiple Compression

    • This is the most likely risk
    • At 23x earnings, any disappointment could send shares 20-30% lower
    • Assessment: HIGH probability in any market correction

The honest risk assessment: Business risk is low. Valuation risk is elevated.

Valuation Philosophy: Is This Price Justified by This Quality?

Here we encounter the central tension of today's quality investing landscape: The best businesses in the world are rarely cheap.

AmEx trades at 23x earnings. Its 10-year average is 15.5x. The premium reflects:

  • Accelerating international growth
  • Millennial/Gen-Z adoption thesis
  • Improved technology capabilities
  • Lower credit risk than historically perceived

Is a 48% premium to historical average justified? Perhaps partially. But margin of safety requires we do not pay full price for optimistic outcomes.

Graham's teaching is clear: "The margin of safety is always dependent on the price paid. It will be large at one price, small at some higher price, nonexistent at some still higher price."

At $352, the margin of safety is nonexistent. We are paying full price for a wonderful business.

This is not necessarily wrong - Buffett himself has evolved from buying "cigar butts" to buying "wonderful businesses at fair prices." But "fair" and "nonexistent margin of safety" are different conditions.

The Patient Investor's Path: When and How to Act

The wisdom of the Munger approach: "The big money is not in the buying or selling but in the waiting."

What to Wait For:

  1. A Market Correction (Most Likely)

    • A broad 15-20% market decline would likely take AmEx to $280-300
    • This creates the 15%+ margin of safety required for a quality compounder

  2. A Credit Cycle Normalization Scare

    • When credit metrics tick up (even moderately), market often overreacts
    • AmEx's premium customer base means actual losses remain low
    • Fear creates opportunity

  3. A Sector Rotation Out of Financials

    • Interest rate uncertainty, regional bank concerns, or regulatory fears
    • Quality financials get sold with low-quality
    • Discriminate - AmEx is not a regional bank

How to Act When Opportunity Arrives:

Price Level Action Position Size Rationale
$315 Begin accumulating 2% 10% discount to current, initial position
$295 Add aggressively +2% (total 4%) 15% margin of safety
$280 Full position +1% (total 5%) Buffett would buy here

What NOT to Do:

  • Do not chase the stock at current levels because "Buffett owns it"
  • Do not use leverage - a 30% decline would be painful but not permanent
  • Do not trade around the position - this is a 20-year holding
  • Do not panic if credit metrics normalize - expect moderate deterioration

Final Meditation: The Timeless vs. The Timely

American Express represents the rare combination of:

  • Timeless business quality (175-year moat, irreplaceable brand)
  • Timely growth opportunity (Millennial adoption, international expansion)

The timeless quality means you can hold this business for decades without monitoring quarterly earnings obsessively. The moat compounds whether you watch or not.

The timely growth means patient investors should be willing to pay somewhat above historical multiples - but not any multiple.

The synthesis of timeless and timely is this: American Express will be a wonderful investment at the right price. That price is 10-15% below current levels.

As Buffett himself has said: "It's far better to buy a wonderful company at a fair price than a fair company at a wonderful price."

AmEx is a wonderful company. The price is not yet fair enough.

Wait.

"The stock market is a device for transferring money from the impatient to the patient." - Warren Buffett

This meditation was conducted in the spirit of value investing's greatest practitioners. The conclusions are not predictions but disciplined assessments of value versus price. Markets can remain irrational longer than investors can remain solvent. Always maintain liquidity to act when opportunity arrives.

Executive Summary

American Express is a rare Buffett-owned financial compounder with a closed-loop payment network, premium brand positioning, and a 175-year operating history. The company has delivered exceptional returns (ROE 32%+, 5-year CAGR 12.6%) by serving an affluent customer base that spends 3x more than average cardholders. Unlike Visa/Mastercard's pure network plays, AmEx's integrated model combines issuing, network services, and merchant acquiring, creating a unique competitive position.

Verdict: WAIT - Exceptional quality but trading at 23x P/E leaves minimal margin of safety. Accumulate at $295-315 (19-20x normalized earnings).

1. Business Model: The Closed-Loop Advantage

How AmEx Makes Money (One Sentence)

American Express earns discount revenue from merchants (who pay 2.3-2.8% vs. Visa/MC's 1.5-2.0%) for access to high-spending affluent cardholders, plus card fees and net interest income from its premium membership base.

Revenue Mix (FY2025E)

Revenue Source % of Total Description
Discount Revenue ~52% Merchant fees on $1.5T+ billed business
Net Card Fees ~14% Annual fees ($695 Platinum, $250 Gold, etc.)
Net Interest Income ~21% Interest on revolving balances
Other Fees/Services ~13% Travel bookings, forex, insurance

The Closed-Loop Model vs. Open-Loop Networks

Aspect AmEx (Closed-Loop) Visa/MC (Open-Loop)
Owns the Customer Yes - issues cards directly No - banks issue cards
Owns Merchant Relationship Yes - direct acquiring No - separate acquirers
Customer Data Complete transaction data Limited (routing only)
Pricing Power Higher MDR (2.3-2.8%) Lower MDR (~1.5-2.0%)
Credit Risk Yes - on balance sheet No - banks bear risk
Operating Margin ~21% ~50-65%

Key Insight: AmEx accepts lower margins for complete control of the customer relationship and superior data, enabling personalized rewards, targeted offers, and deeper engagement.

2. Moat Assessment: WIDE

Moat Sources

1. Network Effects (Strong)

  • 160 million merchants globally (5x growth since 2017)
  • 80% coverage in top 12 international markets
  • $530B annual Platinum card spending globally creates irresistible merchant economics
  • "Our high-spending cardholders spend 3x more annually than average cardholders on other networks" - CEO Stephen Squeri

2. Brand/Premium Positioning (Very Strong)

  • 175-year heritage (founded 1850)
  • Centurion Lounge network (30+ proprietary lounges, largest in industry)
  • Exclusive partnerships: Formula 1, 27,000+ Resy restaurants, 2,600 premium hotels
  • Brand perceived as status symbol (like owning a Rolex vs. Seiko)

3. Switching Costs (Moderate)

  • Membership Rewards points lock-in (1M+ points is common for affluent users)
  • Accumulated travel credits, hotel status, airline benefits
  • "Over 98% spend retention after product refreshes" - CFO

4. Economies of Scale (Strong)

  • Technology platform serves 100M+ cardholders globally
  • Marketing efficiency: acquired 13M new cards in 2024 (record)
  • Operating expenses down 2% YoY even while investing in growth

Moat Width: WIDE

  • Durability: 20+ years
  • Trend: Widening (Millennial/Gen-Z adoption, international expansion)
  • Competitive Position: #1 premium card issuer globally

Comparison to Visa (V) and Mastercard (MA)

Metric AXP V MA
ROE 32.2% 52% 198%
Net Margin 13.4% 55% 47%
Moat Type Integrated ecosystem Pure network Pure network
Credit Risk Yes No No
Customer Ownership Complete None None
Data Advantage Superior Limited Limited

Why AmEx isn't "inferior": Visa/MC have higher margins but no direct customer relationship. AmEx's lower margins fund superior customer engagement that drives 3x higher spend per card. For investors seeking financial quality with direct customer ownership, AmEx is unique.

3. Financial Analysis

Profitability (Buffett Quality Checks)

Metric AXP Buffett Threshold Result
ROE (Latest) 32.2% >15% PASS
ROE (5yr Avg) 32.5% >15% PASS
Operating Margin 20.6% Stable/Improving PASS
FCF $12.14B Positive PASS
Revenue CAGR (5yr) 12.6% >GDP growth PASS

5-Year Financial Summary

Year Revenue ($B) Net Income ($B) EPS ROE
2025E 80.5 10.8 $15.39 32.2%
2024 74.2 10.1 $14.01 33.4%
2023 67.4 8.4 $11.21 29.8%
2022 55.6 7.5 $9.84 30.4%
2021 44.4 8.0 $9.99 36.0%

Observation: Consistent ROE above 30% even through COVID (2020 was an anomaly at $3.76 EPS). This stability demonstrates the resilience of the premium customer base.

Balance Sheet

Year Assets ($B) Equity ($B) D/E Ratio Cash ($B)
2025E 300.1 33.5 7.96x 47.8
2024 271.5 30.3 7.97x 40.6

Note on Leverage: D/E of 8x looks alarming but is typical for financial services. AmEx's leverage is funded by customer deposits and ABS securitization of receivables - not risky debt. The key metric is capital ratios:

  • CET1 Ratio: 10.5% (target 10-11%)
  • Stress Capital Buffer: 2.5% (lowest permissible - Fed confirmed best-in-class)
  • CCAR Results: Lowest projected credit card loss rate among all banks

Cash Flow

Year Operating CF ($B) CapEx ($B) FCF ($B) Dividends ($B)
2024 14.05 1.91 12.14 2.00
2023 18.56 1.56 17.00 1.78
2022 21.08 1.85 19.22 1.56

FCF Yield: At $243B market cap, FCF of $12B = ~5% FCF yield

4. Growth Drivers

Near-Term (2025-2027)

  1. Platinum Card Refresh Success

    • "Strongest start we've seen for a US Platinum Card refresh" - CEO
    • New acquisitions at 2x pre-refresh levels
    • 500,000+ requests for new mirror card design
    • FICO scores of new applicants 15 points higher than before

  2. Millennial/Gen-Z Adoption

    • Now 36% of total spend (equal to Gen X)
    • Transactions per customer 25% higher than older cohorts
    • "Gen Z spend growing around 40%" - CFO

  3. International Expansion

    • International up 13-15% FX-adjusted quarterly
    • 80% coverage in top 12 markets (up 8pp from 3 years ago)
    • Under-penetrated: 6% average spend share in top 5 countries

Long-Term Secular Tailwinds

  1. Premium Card Category Growth

    • Fee-based premium cards are fastest-growing segment in US
    • AmEx has ~25% of premium cards = runway for share gains

  2. Digital Payments Shift

    • Cash-to-card conversion accelerating globally
    • AmEx benefits from any card growth

  3. Affluent Demographics

    • High earners growing as share of population
    • Premium travel/experience spending increasing

5. Risk Assessment

Primary Risks

Risk Severity Probability Mitigation
Economic Recession HIGH Medium Premium customer base more resilient (98% retention)
Credit Deterioration HIGH Low Best-in-class credit (below 2019 levels), CCAR validated
Merchant Pushback on MDR Medium Medium Scale and data advantage justify premium
Competition (Chase Sapphire, Capital One) Medium Ongoing Continuous product refresh, brand moat
Regulatory (Durbin Amendment expansion) Medium Low Closed-loop network historically exempt

Key Risk: High Merchant Discount Rate

AmEx charges merchants 2.3-2.8% vs. 1.5-2.0% for Visa/MC. Some merchants have tried to drop AmEx or steer customers away. However:

  • AmEx cardholders spend 3x more annually
  • "We've grown merchant acceptance by 5x since 2017" - CEO
  • 160 million merchants globally now accept AmEx

Risk Assessment: Merchant economics favor acceptance. MANAGEABLE.

Credit Quality Deep Dive

From Q3 2025 earnings:

  • Delinquency rates: Still below 2019 levels
  • Write-off rates: Declined sequentially
  • New Platinum customer FICO: 15 points higher post-refresh
  • "Our delinquency rate for Millennial and Gen Z customers are nearly 40% better than industry average for older age groups" - CFO

Credit Risk Assessment: BEST-IN-CLASS

6. Valuation

Current Valuation

Metric Value Assessment
Price $352.17
P/E (TTM) 22.9x Above historical average
P/E (Forward) 20.1x Reasonable for quality
P/B 7.2x Premium brand commands premium
FCF Yield ~5% Acceptable
Dividend Yield 0.93% Low but growing

Historical Valuation Context

Period Average P/E Current vs. Avg
5-Year Average 17.5x +31% premium
10-Year Average 15.5x +48% premium
COVID Low (2020) 8.5x +169%
Pre-COVID High (2019) 16x +43%

Assessment: Trading at significant premium to history, justified partially by improved growth trajectory and Millennial adoption.

Fair Value Estimate

Method 1: Earnings Multiple

  • Normalized EPS: $15.50-16.00
  • Fair P/E for quality compounder: 18-20x
  • Fair Value: $280-320

Method 2: DCF (10-Year, 10% Discount Rate)

  • Starting FCF: $12B
  • Growth Years 1-5: 8% (management guidance low-end)
  • Growth Years 6-10: 5%
  • Terminal Multiple: 15x FCF
  • Intrinsic Value: $290-310

Method 3: P/E Expansion/Compression Scenario

Scenario P/E EPS Price Probability
Bull 22x $18.00 $396 25%
Base 19x $16.50 $314 50%
Bear 15x $14.00 $210 25%
Probability-Weighted $299

Entry Prices

Level Price P/E Margin of Safety
Strong Buy $280 17x 15%+
Accumulate $315 19x 5-10%
Current $352 22.9x 0%
Overvalued $400+ 25x+ Negative

7. Superinvestor Context

Warren Buffett's Position

  • Holding Period: Since 1990s (~30+ years)
  • Portfolio Weight: 18.8% of Berkshire
  • Cost Basis: Estimated ~$8-12/share (adjusted)
  • Unrealized Gain: ~3,000%+

Why Buffett Loves AmEx:

  1. Brand moat ("I'll never sell AmEx" - paraphrased)
  2. Pricing power (can raise fees)
  3. Affluent customer base (recession-resilient)
  4. Management quality (Steve Squeri since 2018)
  5. Capital return (repurchased 17% of shares since 2019)

Guy Spier's Position

  • Portfolio Weight: 22%
  • Thesis: "Own the toll road on affluent spending"
  • Concentration: One of his largest positions

What the Superinvestors Know

Both Buffett and Spier are not selling despite the stock tripling in 5 years. This suggests:

  1. They believe the moat is widening
  2. Millennial/Gen-Z adoption extends the growth runway
  3. International expansion is material
  4. Current valuation, while high, is not absurd for the quality

8. Management Assessment

CEO: Stephen Squeri

  • Tenure: Since 2018 (8 years)
  • Background: 40+ years at AmEx, rose through ranks
  • Strategy: "Back Our Customers" philosophy
  • Track Record:
    • Revenue CAGR 12.6% under his leadership
    • Pivoted to digital/Millennial focus
    • Navigated COVID without major losses
    • 200+ product refreshes since 2019

Capital Allocation

Action 2024 Assessment
Share Repurchases $5.9B Aggressive - reduced share count 17% since 2019
Dividends $2.0B 17% increase annually, doubled since 2019
CapEx $1.9B Focused (technology, lounges)

Skin in the Game:

  • Insider ownership: 22.1%
  • Management has significant equity tied to performance

9. Comparison: AXP vs. V vs. MA

For context vs. the WAIT list entries:

Metric AXP V MA
Current P/E 22.9x 35.5x 42.4x
ROE 32% 52% 198%
Revenue Growth 10% 10% 11%
Net Margin 13% 55% 47%
Dividend Yield 0.9% 0.7% 0.5%
Moat Type Integrated Pure Network Pure Network
Credit Risk Yes No No
Valuation Fair Expensive Very Expensive

Verdict: AXP offers better value than V/MA but has more credit risk. For investors comfortable with financial leverage and seeking direct customer ownership, AXP is preferred. For pure network exposure with lower risk, V is better at $275.

10. Investment Thesis

Bull Case (30% Probability)

  • Revenue grows 10%+ annually (high-end guidance)
  • Millennial/Gen-Z become dominant cohort
  • International reaches 50% of revenue
  • P/E expands to 24-25x on growth
  • Target Price: $425-450 (3-year)

Base Case (50% Probability)

  • Revenue grows 8-9% annually
  • Margins stable at 13-14%
  • P/E compresses to 19-20x
  • Target Price: $350-380 (3-year) - limited upside from here

Bear Case (20% Probability)

  • Recession causes credit spike
  • Merchant pushback increases
  • Competition erodes premium positioning
  • P/E compresses to 15x
  • Target Price: $210-250

11. Verdict and Action Plan

Recommendation: WAIT

Quality Grade: A (passes all Buffett tests)

  • ROE 32%+ > 15% threshold
  • Consistent earnings growth
  • Wide moat (brand + network effects)
  • Excellent management
  • Strong FCF generation

Valuation Grade: C+ (fair but no margin of safety)

  • P/E 23x vs. 17.5x 5-year average
  • Limited upside in base case
  • Needs 15%+ pullback for margin of safety

Entry Prices

Level Price P/E Action
Strong Buy $280 17x Full position (5%)
Accumulate $315 19x Half position (2.5%)
Hold $350 21x No new buys
Trim $400 24x Consider reducing

Catalysts to Watch

Positive (Could Accelerate Entry):

  • Market correction (-15%+ pullback)
  • Economic slowdown fears (temporary)
  • Credit cycle normalization (earnings dip)

Negative (Would Increase Caution):

  • Merchant revolt (Costco-style defection)
  • Regulatory action on MDR
  • Sustained credit deterioration

Final Word

American Express is Buffett's longest-held financial for a reason - the brand moat, premium positioning, and customer loyalty create a durable competitive advantage. The Millennial/Gen-Z adoption story extends the growth runway by decades. However, at 23x earnings with the stock up 192% in 5 years, the market has recognized this quality.

Wait for a 10-15% pullback to build a position. Set alerts at $315 (Accumulate) and $280 (Strong Buy). This is a generational compounder you want to own - just at the right price.

Analysis conducted using Warren Buffett value investing methodology. Data sources: AlphaVantage MCP, company earnings transcripts Q4 2024 - Q3 2025, company filings. All views are for educational purposes.