Executive Summary
Berkshire Hathaway remains a core holding worthy of continued ownership. The company delivered exceptional 2024 results with underwriting profits up 66%, a record $334B cash position, and successful navigation of the CEO succession announcement. While the Buffett retirement creates uncertainty, Greg Abel's track record and the decentralized culture provide continuity. The stock trades at 1.55x book value - modestly above historical averages but justified by improved insurance results and optionality from the massive cash hoard.
VERDICT: HOLD at current levels | ACCUMULATE on pullbacks below $450
Part 1: Business Overview
Corporate Structure
Berkshire Hathaway is a diversified holding company organized into three major segments:
Insurance & Reinsurance (Float: $171B)
- GEICO - Auto insurance (#2 in US)
- General Re - Global reinsurer
- Berkshire Hathaway Reinsurance Group
- Berkshire Hathaway Primary Group
Railroad & Utilities
- BNSF Railway - Largest freight railroad in North America
- Berkshire Hathaway Energy - Major utility holding company
Manufacturing, Service & Retailing (189 operating businesses)
- Precision Castparts, Lubrizol, IMC, Marmon
- See's Candies, Dairy Queen, NetJets
- Business Wire, FlightSafety, Clayton Homes
Investment Portfolio
- $300B+ in public equities (reduced from $400B+ in 2023)
- Major holdings: Apple, Bank of America, Coca-Cola, American Express, Chevron
Part 2: Insurance Operations Analysis
Insurance Float - The Engine of Berkshire
| Year | Float | YoY Growth |
|---|---|---|
| 2024 | $171B | +1.2% |
| 2023 | $169B | +3.0% |
| 2022 | $164B | +11.6% |
| 2021 | $147B | +6.5% |
| 2020 | $138B | +7.0% |
| 2019 | $129B | Base |
5-Year Float Growth: 32.6%
The insurance float represents policyholder premiums held before claims are paid. For Berkshire, this is essentially free financing (often negative-cost when underwriting is profitable) that funds investments.
2024 Underwriting Results
| Segment | 2024 Pre-Tax Profit | 2023 Pre-Tax Profit | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| GEICO | $7.8B | $3.6B | +117% |
| BHRG (Reinsurance) | $2.7B | $1.9B | +42% |
| BH Primary | $0.86B | $1.4B | -39% |
| Total | $9.0B | $5.4B | +66% |
Key Observations:
- GEICO's turnaround under Todd Combs is remarkable - combined ratio improved to 81.5%
- Reinsurance benefited from hard market pricing
- Primary group hit by higher loss costs
- Total underwriting profit of $9B is exceptional
Combined Ratio Analysis
GEICO's combined ratio of 81.5% means for every $1 of premium, only $0.815 goes to claims and expenses - leaving 18.5 cents of underwriting profit. This is world-class performance.
Part 3: Operating Businesses Analysis
BNSF Railway
| Metric | 2024 | 2023 | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | $23.4B | $23.5B | -0.5% |
| Pre-Tax Earnings | $6.6B | $6.6B | +0.5% |
| Net Income | $5.0B | $5.1B | -1.1% |
| Operating Ratio | 68.0% | 68.4% | +0.4 pts |
| Volume Growth | +6.5% | N/A | Strong |
Assessment: BNSF is performing adequately but not exceptionally. The railroad faces secular headwinds from coal decline but is seeing strong intermodal growth. The 68% operating ratio is good but trails peers like Union Pacific. Buffett's comment that the railroad has "much left to accomplish" suggests room for improvement.
Berkshire Hathaway Energy
BHE contributed approximately $3.3B in 2024 earnings (rebounding from wildfire litigation losses in 2023). The utility business provides stable, regulated returns and is a major beneficiary of renewable energy investment.
Headwinds: Wildfire liability risk in Western states remains a concern. BHE booked $1.3B in estimated losses from the January 2025 LA wildfires.
Manufacturing, Service & Retailing
This segment earned approximately $12-13B pre-tax in 2024. Key points:
- 189 operating businesses
- 53% reported earnings declines in 2024
- Manufacturing held steady
- Service and retail weaker (down 20%+ in Q3)
Part 4: Investment Portfolio Analysis
Major Equity Holdings (as of Q3 2024)
| Company | Value | % of Portfolio |
|---|---|---|
| Apple | $69.9B | ~28% |
| Bank of America | $31.7B | ~13% |
| American Express | $28.3B | ~11% |
| Coca-Cola | $25.5B | ~10% |
| Chevron | $17.5B | ~7% |
| Other | ~$75B | ~31% |
| Total | ~$248B | 100% |
The Apple Liquidation
Berkshire's Apple sales in 2024 were transformational:
- Sold $143B worth of equities (net) in 2024
- Apple position reduced 67% from Q3 2023
- Realized gains of approximately $95B
- Paid ~$27B in federal taxes on gains
Motivations:
- Tax planning - Buffett expects higher capital gains taxes
- Concentration risk reduction - Apple was 45% of portfolio
- Valuation concerns - Apple trades at premium multiples
- Optionality building - Cash for future opportunities
Record Cash Position
| Component | Amount |
|---|---|
| Cash & Equivalents | $47.7B |
| Short-Term T-Bills | $286.5B |
| Total Cash | $334.2B |
This $334B cash position represents:
- 32% of Berkshire's market capitalization
- 51% of shareholders' equity
- Earning ~5% on T-Bills = $16.7B annually
Implications:
- Opportunity Optionality: Dry powder for major acquisitions
- Market Skepticism: Buffett sees limited attractive opportunities
- Economic Hedging: Prepared for market dislocation
- Tax-Efficient: T-Bill interest taxed lower than dividends
Part 5: Succession Analysis
The Transition
Timeline:
- May 2021: Greg Abel announced as heir apparent
- May 2025: Buffett announces year-end 2025 retirement
- January 1, 2026: Abel becomes CEO
- Ongoing: Howard Buffett becomes non-executive Chairman
About Greg Abel
- Age: 63
- Background: Canadian, joined Berkshire via MidAmerican Energy (2000)
- Current Role: Vice Chairman of Non-Insurance Operations
- Track Record: Built BHE into major utility ($24B revenue)
- Investing: Less proven than Buffett, but supported by Ted Weschler/Todd Combs
Risk Assessment
| Factor | Risk Level | Commentary |
|---|---|---|
| Operating Execution | LOW | Abel proven operator |
| Culture Preservation | LOW-MEDIUM | Decentralized model should persist |
| Capital Allocation | MEDIUM | Key uncertainty |
| Investment Returns | MEDIUM-HIGH | Hard to replicate Buffett |
| Acquisition Pipeline | MEDIUM | Relationships matter |
Stock Impact: BRK-B fell 15% in the three months following the May announcement, recovering to -8.4% by recent close. Some "Buffett premium" erosion is expected.
Part 6: Valuation Analysis
Book Value Approach (Buffett's Traditional Metric)
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Shareholders' Equity | $649B |
| Class B Equivalent Shares | ~2.16B |
| Book Value Per B Share | ~$301 |
| Current Price | $501 |
| Price/Book | 1.66x |
Historical P/B Range: 1.2x - 1.8x Current: At higher end of historical range
Sum-of-Parts Valuation
| Component | Value | Method |
|---|---|---|
| Insurance (Float) | $171B | 1.0x float |
| BNSF Railway | $100B | ~16x earnings |
| BH Energy | $50B | ~15x earnings |
| Mfg/Service/Retail | $150B | ~12x earnings |
| Investment Portfolio | $248B | Market value |
| Cash & T-Bills | $334B | Face value |
| Less: Deferred Taxes | $(80B) | Estimated |
| Total Intrinsic Value | $973B | |
| Per B Share | ~$450 |
Current Price: $501 Sum-of-Parts Value: ~$450 Premium to SOTP: ~11%
Note: The premium may reflect optionality value of cash deployment and insurance earnings power.
Look-Through Earnings Approach
| Component | 2024 Earnings |
|---|---|
| Insurance Underwriting | $9.0B |
| BNSF (after-tax) | $5.0B |
| BH Energy | $3.3B |
| Mfg/Service/Retail | $10.0B |
| Investment Income | $16.7B |
| Total Look-Through | $44.0B |
At 2.16B Class B shares: $20.37 per share in look-through earnings
Look-Through P/E: $501 / $20.37 = 24.6x
This is reasonable for a high-quality conglomerate but not cheap.
Fair Value Estimate
Combining multiple approaches:
| Method | Fair Value/Share |
|---|---|
| 1.4x Book Value | $420 |
| 1.5x Book Value | $450 |
| Sum-of-Parts | $450 |
| 18x Look-Through | $370 |
| 22x Look-Through | $450 |
| Average | $428 |
Fair Value Range: $400-$475
Current Price ($501): Trading at 5-10% premium to mid-range fair value
Part 7: Risk Analysis
Key Risks
| Risk | Probability | Impact | Mitigation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Succession Execution | Medium | High | Decentralized culture, proven team |
| Insurance Mega-Cat | Low | High | Diversified, strong reserves |
| Interest Rate Decline | Medium | Medium | Short-duration T-Bills |
| Railroad Disruption | Low | Medium | Irreplaceable infrastructure |
| Concentration (Apple) | Low | Medium | Already reduced significantly |
| Regulatory/Political | Low | Low | Well-capitalized, compliant |
Thesis-Breaking Events to Monitor
- Post-Buffett capital allocation errors - Large, value-destroying acquisitions
- Insurance underwriting deterioration - Combined ratios exceeding 100%
- Major culture exodus - Key managers leaving
- Dramatic cash destruction - Poor investment timing
Part 8: Investment Thesis
Bull Case ($550-600)
- Greg Abel proves capable steward
- Cash deployed at attractive returns
- Insurance continues excellent underwriting
- BNSF operational improvements
- Multiple expansion as transition concerns fade
Base Case ($480-520)
- Steady-as-she-goes operations
- Modest earnings growth (5-7% annually)
- Cash remains largely in T-Bills
- P/B stays around 1.4-1.5x
- Ongoing buybacks at dips
Bear Case ($380-420)
- Capital allocation mistakes
- Insurance mega-cat losses
- Recession impacts railroads and manufacturing
- P/B compresses to 1.2x on uncertainty
- "Buffett premium" fully erodes
Part 9: Recommendation
For Current Shareholders (OWNED Position)
HOLD the current position. Berkshire remains a high-quality, diversified business with:
- Exceptional insurance franchise
- Hard assets in railroads and utilities
- Massive cash providing optionality
- Proven management succession plan
Action Points
| Price Level | Action | Rationale |
|---|---|---|
| $500+ | HOLD | Fair value, no action needed |
| $460-500 | HOLD/LIGHT ADD | Approaching value |
| $420-460 | ACCUMULATE | 10-15% discount to fair value |
| Below $400 | STRONG BUY | Significant margin of safety |
Position Sizing
Berkshire is suitable for a 5-10% portfolio allocation as a core holding. Its low beta (0.70), diversification, and cash position make it a stabilizing force.
Part 10: Final Verdict
=== VERDICT: BRK.B | HOLD | Fair Value: $450 | Accumulate Below: $420 | Reason: Quality franchise at fair price, succession well-managed, $334B cash provides optionality ===
Summary Metrics
| Metric | Value | Assessment |
|---|---|---|
| Current Price | $501.34 | Slightly above fair value |
| Fair Value | $450 | Based on multiple methods |
| Margin of Safety | -11% | Price exceeds value |
| 5-Year Return | +121% | Excellent |
| Dividend | None | Uses buybacks instead |
| Risk Level | Low | Diversified conglomerate |
Key Monitoring Points
- Q4 2024 / Q1 2025 earnings for post-Buffett baseline
- Greg Abel's first major capital allocation decision
- Insurance combined ratios
- Cash deployment or continued accumulation
- Share buyback activity
Sources
- Berkshire Hathaway 2024 Annual Shareholder Letter
- Berkshire Hathaway Q3 2024 10-Q
- Berkshire Hathaway Annual Reports
- Morningstar - Berkshire 13F Analysis
- CNBC - Berkshire Portfolio Tracker
- Yahoo Finance - Warren Buffett Steps Down
- AlphaVantage MCP Server (Financial Statements)
- EODHD MCP Server (Historical Prices)
Analysis completed December 25, 2025