Executive Summary

Cembra Money Bank is Switzerland's leading specialist consumer finance bank, offering personal loans, auto leasing, credit cards, and BNPL products. The company was formerly GE Capital's Swiss consumer finance unit and has been publicly listed since its November 2013 IPO. With ROE around 13.7%, operating margins near 48%, net margins of 33%, and a 13-year unbroken dividend growth record, Cembra is a well-run, predictable business operating in a highly regulated Swiss market. However, the stock has rallied ~70% from its 2023 lows and now trades at P/E 15.8x and P/B 2.1x -- reasonable but offering limited margin of safety. The narrow moat is real but not exceptional, and structural headwinds from Swiss interest rate caps, personal loan shrinkage, and the loss of the Migros partnership limit upside.

Verdict: Quality B+ Swiss consumer finance business at fair value. WAIT for a pullback to CHF 75-80 (P/E ~12-13x, ~4.5-5% yield) for meaningful margin of safety.

---

Phase 0: Opportunity Identification (Klarman)

Why Does This Opportunity Exist?

1. Neglect / Limited Coverage: Cembra is a mid-cap Swiss stock (CHF 2.8B) with limited international analyst coverage. It trades only on the SIX Swiss Exchange and is not easily accessible to US/UK investors. AlphaVantage and EODHD APIs have zero coverage -- this stock is genuinely under-followed outside Switzerland.

2. Post-Migros Recovery Fully Priced: The stock cratered 37% in 2021 when Migros terminated its Cumulus Mastercard partnership (announced August 2021, effective June 2022). This was Cembra's largest credit card partnership. The company launched its own "Certo!" card family and has recovered financially -- but the stock has already rallied 70%+ from the 2023 lows. The recovery is priced in.

3. Swiss Market Premium: Swiss financial stocks command valuation premiums due to the country's stability, strong currency, and robust regulatory environment. This is partly warranted but limits upside.

At current prices (CHF 96.45), the opportunity is limited. The stock is at fair value. No catalyst-driven mispricing exists.

---

Phase 1: Risk Analysis (Inversion)

"What Would Destroy This Investment?"

1. INTEREST RATE CAP COMPRESSION

Probability: HIGH | Impact: MEDIUM-HIGH

Swiss consumer credit is subject to statutory maximum interest rates set by the Federal Department of Justice and Police. The current cap is 10% APR for cash loans and 12% for overdrafts/credit cards (as of Jan 1, 2026). This cap is calculated as SARON + 10 percentage points for cash loans.

With the SNB having cut rates by 175 basis points since March 2024 (policy rate now at 0.00%), the regulatory formula will mechanically lower the maximum APR further. If SARON goes negative, the ceiling drops below 10%. Cembra's net interest margin of 5.5% could compress to 4.5-5.0%, directly impacting profitability.

Already visible: Net revenues declined 2% in FY2025 (CHF 542M vs CHF 551M in FY2024) driven by lower interest income following maximum rate reductions. Net interest income fell 2% to CHF 372M.

Kill Zone: If the SNB implements negative rates again and the cap falls to 8-9%, Cembra's entire business model -- earning ~5.5% NIM on CHF 6.6B of receivables -- faces structural margin compression.

2. PERSONAL LOAN PORTFOLIO SHRINKAGE

Probability: MEDIUM-HIGH | Impact: MEDIUM

Personal loans (CHF 2.15B, 33% of receivables) declined 6% in FY2025. This is not a one-year blip. Swiss consumer credit demand is structurally challenged by:

• Low unemployment (2.3%) reducing distress borrowing
• Conservative Swiss culture regarding consumer debt
• Low interest rate environment encouraging bank alternatives
• Digital challengers offering competitive rates

If personal loans continue declining 3-5% annually, Cembra must replace this revenue with auto leasing or cards -- segments with different risk profiles.

3. CREDIT CYCLE DETERIORATION

Probability: MEDIUM | Impact: HIGH

Cembra's loss rate has been remarkably stable at 1.0-1.1% for years. But this is partly a function of the benign Swiss economic environment. In a severe recession:

• Loss rates could spike to 2-3%+
• Auto values would decline (collateral impairment)
• Personal loan defaults would surge
• Provision charges would consume a large portion of net income

With CHF 6.6B in receivables, even a 1 percentage point increase in losses wipes out CHF 66M in pre-tax income -- roughly 30% of current net income.

4. REGULATORY TIGHTENING

Probability: MEDIUM | Impact: MEDIUM

Beyond interest rate caps, Swiss regulators could:

• Tighten creditworthiness assessments (reduce addressable market)
• Impose additional capital requirements on consumer lenders
• Restrict auto leasing terms
• Regulate BNPL products more aggressively

FINMA and the Swiss Consumer Credit Act already impose strict requirements. Further tightening would raise compliance costs and shrink the addressable market.

5. DIGITAL DISRUPTION

Probability: LOW-MEDIUM | Impact: MEDIUM

Fintech lenders (Neon, Revolut, N26) and big-bank digital offerings could erode Cembra's position in:

• Credit cards (competition from Swisscard AECS, bank-issued cards)
• Personal loans (online comparison platforms drive rate competition)
• BNPL (Klarna, Afterpay entering Swiss market)

Cembra's BNPL portfolio already shrank 17% in FY2025 to CHF 131M -- a warning sign that digital-native competitors may be winning this segment.

Inversion Section

How could this lose 50%+ permanently? Swiss financial crisis + regulatory cap squeeze + loss rate spike to 3%+. At CHF 48, the stock would trade at 0.9x book value and 8x depressed earnings. This would require a severe recession or Swiss property crash -- unlikely but not impossible.

What would make me sell immediately (non-price triggers)?

• Loss rate exceeding 2.0% for two consecutive quarters
• ROE falling below 10% sustainably
• Management pursuing aggressive growth outside Switzerland
• Tier 1 capital ratio dropping below 14%

3-sentence bear case: Cembra is a low-growth consumer lender in a country where interest rate caps mechanically compress margins as rates fall. Personal loans -- the highest-margin product -- are structurally shrinking. At P/E 16x with 2-3% EPS growth, the stock offers a ~10% total return (4.4% yield + ~5% growth) that barely compensates for banking sector risks.

---

Phase 2: Financial Analysis

Return Metrics

ROE Trend:

ROE averaging 13.5% over 5 years. This fails Buffett's >15% ROE test, though it approaches the target. For a Swiss bank with conservative risk management, 13-14% ROE is respectable but not exceptional.

DuPont Decomposition (FY2025):

• Net Margin: 33.1% (CHF 180M / CHF 542M)
• Asset Turnover: 0.068x (CHF 542M / CHF 7,943M)
• Equity Multiplier: 5.9x (CHF 7,943M / CHF 1,345M)

ROE = 33.1% x 0.068 x 5.9 = 13.3% (approximately matches reported 13.7%)

The high net margin is offset by extremely low asset turnover (characteristic of banks) and moderate leverage.

Owner Earnings Calculation: For banks, owner earnings ~ net income - required capital retention for growth.

Owner Earnings = Net Income - Growth Capital Needs = CHF 180M - (~CHF 60M retained for capital adequacy) = ~CHF 120M

Owner Earnings per share = CHF 120M / 29.3M shares = CHF 4.10/share

Valuation

Graham Number:

Graham Number = sqrt(22.5 x EPS x BVPS)
= sqrt(22.5 x 6.13 x 45.92)
= sqrt(6,331)
= CHF 79.57

Current price CHF 96.45 is 21% above the Graham Number. No Graham margin of safety.

Earnings Power Value (Conservative):

• Normalized EPS: CHF 5.80 (average of 2021-2025)
• Conservative multiple for Swiss consumer bank: 12-14x
• EPV Low: CHF 5.80 x 12 = CHF 69.60
• EPV Mid: CHF 5.80 x 13 = CHF 75.40
• EPV High: CHF 5.80 x 14 = CHF 81.20

DCF (Conservative): Assumptions:

• Starting owner earnings: CHF 120M
• Growth: 3% for years 1-5, 2% terminal
• Discount rate: 9% (Swiss equity risk premium)

DCF Value = Σ [120M x (1.03)^n / (1.09)^n] + Terminal Value / (1.09)^5
Year 1-5 PV: ~CHF 476M
Terminal Value PV: ~CHF 1,240M
Total: ~CHF 1,716M
Per share: CHF 58.56

This is very conservative -- applying a discount rate of 9% to a Swiss bank is harsh. At 7.5% discount rate:

Year 1-5 PV: ~CHF 495M
Terminal Value PV: ~CHF 1,618M
Total: ~CHF 2,113M
Per share: CHF 72.08

Private Market Value: A strategic acquirer (e.g., UBS, Zurich Cantonal Bank, or a European consumer finance group) would likely pay:

• 1.5-2.0x book value (book = CHF 45.92)
• Private market value: CHF 69-92 per share
• At current price of CHF 96.45, the stock trades ABOVE the likely private market value

Relative Valuation:

Cembra trades at a premium to European consumer finance peers, justified partly by Swiss stability but still leaving limited upside.

Margin of Safety Summary

Current price offers NO margin of safety by any valuation methodology.

---

Phase 3: Moat Analysis

Moat Sources

1. Regulatory Barriers to Entry (NARROW MOAT)

Swiss banking regulation creates a meaningful barrier to entry:

• Banking license requirement from FINMA
• Capital adequacy requirements (17.6% Tier 1)
• Swiss Consumer Credit Act compliance
• Strict creditworthiness assessment rules
• AML/KYC requirements

Foreign fintechs cannot easily enter the Swiss consumer credit market without a banking license or partnership with a licensed institution. This protects incumbents.

However: Swiss universal banks (UBS, cantonal banks) already operate in this space and could expand if they chose to. The regulatory moat protects against foreign entrants, not domestic competition.

2. Distribution Network (NARROW MOAT)

• ~4,000 car dealer partnerships for auto financing
• 13 branches + online presence
• Credit card partnerships (IKEA Family, Certo! card family)
• Established savings deposit base (CHF 3.6B)

This distribution network took decades to build and would be expensive to replicate. But it's not irreplaceable -- a well-capitalized competitor could build similar relationships within 3-5 years.

3. Data & Underwriting Expertise (NARROW MOAT)

20+ years of Swiss consumer credit data (originally from GE Capital era since 1998). This enables:

• Superior credit scoring models
• Tight loss performance (1.0-1.1% loss rate)
• Efficient risk-based pricing

4. Switching Costs (MINIMAL)

Consumer loans have low switching costs. Borrowers can refinance at maturity. Credit card switching is moderate (behavioral inertia) but the Migros exit proved that partnership-based card portfolios can evaporate quickly.

Moat Durability Assessment

Moat Width: NARROW Moat Trend: STABLE (not widening, not narrowing) 10-Year Trajectory: Same width -- regulatory protection persists but competitive pressures also persist.

---

Phase 4: Management & Capital Allocation

Management Team

CEO: Holger Laubenthal

• Leading strategic transformation focused on cost efficiency
• Targeting 39% cost/income ratio (from 45.2% in FY2025)
• ROE target of ~15%
• New strategic cycle to be unveiled Q4 2026

Capital Allocation Track Record

Management demonstrates disciplined, shareholder-friendly capital allocation. The progressive dividend policy with a floor at the prior year's level provides downside protection for income investors. The extraordinary dividend in 2025 signals confidence in excess capital position.

Insider Ownership

Limited public data on insider ownership. Swiss corporate governance typically features lower insider ownership than US companies. The company does not appear to have a controlling shareholder.

---

Phase 5: Catalyst Analysis

Positive Catalysts

Negative Catalysts

Net Assessment: No strong near-term catalyst for upside. The stock has already rallied on the recovery story. Further upside requires execution on the 39% cost/income target and ROE improvement toward 15%.

---

Phase 6: Decision Synthesis

Intrinsic Value Estimate

Weighting the valuation methodologies:

Weighted Intrinsic Value: ~CHF 78 per share

At current price of CHF 96.45, the stock is ~24% overvalued relative to intrinsic value.

Price Targets

Strong Buy:       CHF 55   (P/E ~9x, P/B 1.2x, Yield 8.4%)
Accumulate:       CHF 70   (P/E ~11.4x, P/B 1.5x, Yield 6.6%)
Fair Value:       CHF 78   (P/E ~12.7x, P/B 1.7x, Yield 5.9%)
Current:          CHF 96.45 (P/E 15.8x, P/B 2.1x, Yield 4.4%)
Take Profits:     CHF 94   (P/E ~15.3x)
Sell:             CHF 117  (P/E ~19x, P/B 2.5x)

Expected Return

Total expected return is slightly negative -- confirming the stock is at or above fair value.

Recommendation

+---------------------------------------------------------------+
|                 INVESTMENT RECOMMENDATION                       |
+---------------------------------------------------------------+
| Company: Cembra Money Bank AG    Ticker: CMBN.SW               |
| Current Price: CHF 96.45         Date: Feb 21, 2026            |
+---------------------------------------------------------------+
| RECOMMENDATION:  [x] WAIT                                      |
+---------------------------------------------------------------+
| STRONG BUY:        CHF 55    (30%+ MOS, P/E ~9x)              |
| ACCUMULATE:        CHF 70    (10% MOS, P/E ~11.4x)            |
| FAIR VALUE:        CHF 78    (intrinsic value)                 |
| CURRENT PRICE:     CHF 96.45 (24% above IV)                   |
| TAKE PROFITS:      CHF 94    (if owned)                        |
| SELL:              CHF 117   (50% above IV)                    |
+---------------------------------------------------------------+
| GAP TO ACCUMULATE: -27.4%                                       |
| DIVIDEND YIELD (CURRENT): 4.41% ordinary, 5.81% total         |
| PRIMARY RISK: Interest rate cap compression squeezing NIM      |
| SELL TRIGGER: Loss rate >2.0%, ROE <10%, Tier 1 <14%          |
+---------------------------------------------------------------+

Sell Triggers (Pre-Defined)

1. Thesis Break: Loss rate exceeds 2.0% for two consecutive quarters
2. Moat Erosion: Personal loan portfolio declines >10% annually for 2+ years
3. Management Failure: Pursuing aggressive acquisitions outside Switzerland
4. Valuation: Price exceeds CHF 117 (50% above IV)

Monitoring Metrics

---

Sources

Primary Documents

Web Sources