Back to Portfolio
T6I

ValueMax Group Limited

$1.22 1.1B market cap February 22, 2026
ValueMax Group Limited T6I BUFFETT / MUNGER / KLARMAN SUMMARY
1 SNAPSHOT
Price$1.22
Market Cap1.1B
2 BUSINESS

ValueMax is a well-run family business with a strong brand position in Singapore's regulated pawnbroking industry. The company has delivered impressive headline growth with revenue and net income compounding at 13% and 25% CAGR respectively over five years. However, the business is fundamentally a leveraged gold proxy, not a true compounder. With 0.8 correlation to gold prices, persistent negative free cash flow, debt that has more than doubled to S$701M, and 50%+ share dilution via scrip dividends, the quality of earnings compounding is lower than headline ROE suggests. At SGD 1.22 (12.1x peak earnings, 2.04x book), the stock prices in continued record gold prices with no margin of safety. The patient investor should wait for a gold correction or market selloff to create an entry at SGD 0.80 or below, where the leveraged upside from the next gold cycle would provide meaningful returns.

3 MOAT NARROW

Trusted brand with 47 Singapore outlets, regulatory capital requirements (S$2M per shop), first-mover as SGX-listed pawnbroker, highest loan balance per outlet among listed peers

4 MANAGEMENT
CEO: Yeah Chia Kai

C+ - Consistent dividend growth but systematic shareholder dilution via scrip dividends, heavy debt-funded growth, and persistently negative FCF despite record profitability

5 ECONOMICS
19.7% Op Margin
7% ROIC
18.7% ROE
12.1x P/E
-0.068B FCF
132% Debt/EBITDA
6 VALUATION
FCF Yield-5.9%
DCF Range0.72 - 0.9

Overvalued by 36-69% -- stock prices in peak cycle earnings and record gold prices

7 MUNGER INVERSION
Kill Event Severity P() E[Loss]
Gold price dependency (0.8 correlation to share price, 0.96 to retail revenue) -- a gold correction from all-time highs would significantly impair earnings HIGH - -
Persistent negative free cash flow requires continual debt funding; total debt more than doubled in 5 years to S$701M MED - -
8 KLARMAN LENS
Downside Case

Gold price dependency (0.8 correlation to share price, 0.96 to retail revenue) -- a gold correction from all-time highs would significantly impair earnings

Why Market Right

Gold price correction from all-time highs -- most significant risk to earnings; Rising interest rates increasing funding costs on S$701M debt; Continued share dilution through scrip dividends and bonus issues

Catalysts

Continued gold price appreciation driven by geopolitical tensions and central bank buying; Expansion of higher-margin moneylending and property financing segments; Accretive pawnshop acquisitions (Heng Heng, Ban Fook completed March 2025); Counter-cyclical demand if Singapore enters economic downturn

9 VERDICT WAIT
B Quality Moderate - Profitable with growing equity, but S$701M debt, negative FCF, and 1.37x D/E create vulnerability to gold price declines
Strong Buy$0.65
Buy$0.8
Fair Value$0.9

Set alert at SGD 0.80 (Accumulate) and SGD 0.65 (Strong Buy). Only enter during gold price corrections when the leveraged downside has played out.

🧠 ULTRATHINK Deep Philosophical Analysis

T6I - Ultrathink Analysis

The Core Question

Is ValueMax Group a genuine compounder -- a business that creates value through operational excellence and competitive moats -- or is it a leveraged derivative of the gold price, dressed up in impressive-looking financial metrics?

This distinction matters enormously. A compounder can be bought at fair value and held for decades, generating returns through the power of retained earnings reinvested at high rates of return. A commodity proxy should only be bought at deep discounts, because the underlying driver (gold prices) follows unpredictable cycles that can erase years of apparent progress in months.

The evidence, when examined with Munger-like rigor, points firmly toward the latter interpretation.

The Gold Illusion

Consider the numbers that look impressive on the surface: revenue growing at 13% CAGR, net income at 25% CAGR, ROE of 18.7%, net margins expanding from 12% to 18%. These are numbers that would make most value investors salivate.

But now consider what is driving them. Gold has risen from approximately USD 1,500 per ounce in 2020 to USD 2,900 in early 2026 -- nearly doubling. ValueMax's own disclosures reveal a 0.96 correlation between gold prices and retail/trading revenue, which accounts for roughly 75% of total revenue. The 0.8 correlation between gold prices and the stock price over four years confirms what should be obvious: ValueMax is a leveraged gold ETF with a pawnshop attached.

The leverage operates through two channels. First, the loan book grows mechanically as gold prices rise -- higher collateral values mean larger loans can be extended against the same physical assets. Second, the retail/trading inventory appreciates in value, creating paper gains that flow through the income statement. Both channels amplify the effect of gold price movements on reported earnings.

This is not value creation. This is asset inflation.

Buffett has been clear throughout his career about the distinction. He has called gold a non-productive asset that "will never produce anything." He would never confuse a business whose earnings rise because the price of an underlying commodity rises with a business that creates value through competitive advantage and operational excellence. Coca-Cola's earnings grow because more people drink Coke. ValueMax's earnings grow primarily because gold costs more.

The Free Cash Flow Problem

Perhaps the most damning evidence against the compounder thesis is the free cash flow statement. Over five years (FY2020-FY2024), ValueMax has generated cumulative net income of approximately S$255 million and cumulative free cash flow of negative S$378 million -- a negative S$633 million divergence.

Where did the cash go? Into the loan book. As gold prices rose, ValueMax extended more loans, requiring more capital. Since the business does not generate enough cash to fund this growth, it borrowed. Total debt has more than doubled from S$319 million to S$701 million.

This is the critical insight that separates genuine quality businesses from capital-intensive ones. A true compounder generates excess cash flow that can be returned to shareholders or reinvested at high rates. ValueMax must borrow to grow. Every dollar of loan book growth requires roughly a dollar of new capital -- there is no flywheel, no scalable advantage, no operating leverage. It is a spread business, earning the differential between its borrowing cost and its lending rate, amplified by the direction of gold prices.

Munger would call this "confusing reported earnings with owner earnings." The owner of ValueMax does not receive the S$83 million in reported net income. They receive dividends of S$19 million (only S$7 million in actual cash, since most shareholders take scrip) while the company borrows another S$61 million to fund operations. The true economic return to shareholders is a fraction of what the income statement suggests.

The Dilution Tax

Speaking of scrip dividends, this mechanism deserves scrutiny. Shares outstanding have grown from 565 million to 943 million over five years -- a 67% increase. Net income grew 144% but EPS grew only 67%. Half of the apparent earnings growth was consumed by dilution.

This is not a benign form of capital allocation. Scrip dividends are effectively a forced equity issuance that transfers value from shareholders who take cash to those who take shares. For the company, it conserves cash (which it desperately needs, given negative FCF). For long-term shareholders, it is a persistent tax on their ownership stake.

An owner-operator with true alignment would either pay cash dividends from genuine free cash flow or not pay dividends at all, retaining earnings for reinvestment. The scrip dividend scheme is a signal that the company cannot afford its dividend policy but maintains it for optics.

The Owner's Mindset Test

Would Buffett own this business for twenty years? Let us apply his criteria:

Simple and understandable? Yes. Pawnbroking is straightforward -- lend against collateral, earn interest, sell unredeemed items.

Consistent operating history? Partially. The company has been profitable throughout, but the earnings trajectory is driven by gold prices, not operational excellence. In a flat or declining gold environment, the growth narrative evaporates.

Favorable long-term prospects? Uncertain. Pawnbroking has existed for millennia and will likely persist, but Singapore's market is mature with 242 licensed shops. Growth comes from gold price appreciation and acquisitions, not organic demand expansion. Fintech lending may gradually erode volumes.

Rational management? Mixed. The family has built a strong brand and professionalized the industry. But the capital allocation -- funding growth with debt while maintaining scrip dividends that dilute shareholders -- suggests management prioritizes empire-building over per-share value creation.

Available at an attractive price? Not currently. At 12.1x peak earnings and 2.04x book during a historic gold price rally, the stock offers no margin of safety.

Buffett would pass. The gold dependency, negative FCF, leverage, and dilution are disqualifying factors for a permanent holding. This is a trade, not an investment.

Risk Inversion: What Could Destroy This Business?

The inversion exercise is revealing. What would need to happen for ValueMax to suffer a permanent loss of value?

  1. Gold correction to USD 1,800/oz (-38%). Revenue would likely decline 30-40%, operating margins would compress as fixed costs remain, and the loan book would shrink as collateral values fall. Net income could fall from S$83M to S$30-40M. At a trough multiple of 7x, the stock would trade at SGD 0.25-0.30 -- a 75-80% decline from current levels. This is not an extreme scenario; gold was at USD 1,800 just three years ago.

  2. Funding crisis. With S$701M in debt and S$17M in cash, ValueMax depends on continuous access to credit markets. A banking sector stress event, credit crunch, or loss of banking relationships could force asset liquidation at distressed prices. The Altman Z-Score of 1.51 (grey zone) suggests this risk is not trivial.

  3. Regulatory change. Singapore could tighten moneylending regulations, reduce the interest rate cap from 1.5%, or increase capital requirements. Each would directly impair profitability.

None of these scenarios would permanently destroy the business, but the combination of gold price sensitivity and leverage means the downside in adverse scenarios is severe. This is not the asymmetric risk profile that value investors seek.

The Patient Investor's Path

The correct approach to ValueMax is to recognize it for what it is: a cyclical, leveraged gold play with a decent brand moat in a regulated industry. It is not a permanent holding. It is a tactical position to be established during gold price corrections and sold during gold price rallies.

The time to buy ValueMax was 2020-2022, when gold was consolidating around USD 1,800-2,000 and the stock traded at SGD 0.40-0.50 (7-8x earnings). Investors who bought then have tripled their money, not because ValueMax is a great business, but because gold doubled.

The time to sell ValueMax -- or at least to avoid initiating new positions -- is now, with gold at all-time highs, the stock at all-time highs, and the market pricing in indefinite continuation of the gold supercycle.

The patient investor should set alerts at SGD 0.80 (8.5x normalized earnings, implying a gold correction to ~USD 2,200) and SGD 0.65 (7x earnings, implying a more significant gold pullback). At those levels, the leveraged upside from the next leg of any gold rally would provide meaningful returns.

The key mental model is this: you are not buying a business that compounds. You are buying a call option on gold prices with a modest income stream attached. Price it accordingly.

Executive Summary

ValueMax Group is Singapore's largest listed pawnbroking chain by market capitalization, operating 47 outlets in Singapore and 21 outlets in Malaysia through associated companies. Founded in 1988 by Yeah Hiang Nam, the company has grown from a single pawnshop to a diversified financial services group encompassing pawnbroking, moneylending, gold trading, and pre-owned jewellery retail. ValueMax was the first pawnbroking chain listed on the SGX Mainboard in 2013.

The company has benefited enormously from soaring gold prices, with its share price rallying ~149% in the past 52 weeks. At current prices, the stock trades at 12.1x trailing earnings and 2.04x book value -- reasonable multiples for a business generating 18.7% ROE. However, the heavy dependence on gold prices for earnings growth, persistent negative free cash flow, and significant share dilution raise questions about the sustainability and quality of the compounding.

Verdict: WAIT - Accumulate at SGD 0.80 or below (8.5x earnings). Strong Buy at SGD 0.65 or below (7x earnings).

1. Business Quality Assessment

Understanding ValueMax's Four Segments

Segment 1: Retail and Trading of Jewellery and Gold (~75% of revenue)

  • Largest revenue contributor -- S$204.8M in H1 2025 alone (17.5% YoY growth)
  • Includes pre-owned jewellery retail and institutional gold trading
  • Revenue tracks gold prices almost perfectly (0.96 correlation)
  • Margins are relatively thin on gold trading but higher on jewellery retail
  • Unredeemed pawn pledges become retail inventory at zero cost

Segment 2: Pawnbroking (~15-18% of revenue)

  • Core business with 47 Singapore outlets and ~21 Malaysia outlets via associates
  • Highest loan balance per outlet among listed peers (S$8.8M vs S$4.7M for MoneyMax)
  • Interest rate of 1% for first month, 1.5% thereafter (capped by law)
  • Six-month redemption windows; over 90% of pledges are redeemed
  • Rising gold prices increase collateral values, enabling larger loan books

Segment 3: Moneylending (~5-7% of revenue)

  • Licensed moneylender providing secured and unsecured loans
  • Property loans (60% LTV on private residential/commercial), personal loans, payday loans
  • Revenues grew 10.7% in H1 2025
  • Higher-margin business complementing pawnbroking

Segment 4: Other Operations (<5% of revenue)

  • Investment holding, auto-finance, dealership financing
  • In FY2024, benefited from S$10.1M one-time gain from listing of associate Well Chip Group Berhad

Quality Metrics

Metric FY2024 FY2023 FY2022 Buffett Threshold Pass?
ROE 18.7% 14.3% 13.0% >15% YES (2024)
Operating Margin 19.7% 19.4% 18.0% >10% YES
Net Margin 18.2% 16.0% 15.5% >10% YES
Debt/Equity 1.37x 1.46x 1.68x <1.0x NO
Current Ratio 1.35 1.48 1.28 >1.5x NO
FCF Positive No No No Yes NO

ValueMax passes profitability thresholds but fails on balance sheet strength and free cash flow generation. The business is fundamentally asset-heavy -- its loan book IS its business, and growing the loan book requires continual capital deployment, which is why FCF has been negative in 4 of the last 5 years.

2. Competitive Moat Analysis

Primary Moat: Brand + Regulatory Barriers (NARROW)

Brand and Trust: ValueMax transformed the pawnbroking industry in Singapore from dingy, stigmatized shops to bright, professional retail spaces. The ValueMax brand carries trust and legitimacy, which matters when customers are pledging treasured personal items. The company was the first pawnbroker on the SGX Mainboard, further enhancing credibility.

Regulatory Barriers:

  • Singapore's Pawnbrokers Act 2015 requires a license from the Ministry of Law
  • Each pawnshop requires S$2M in paid-up capital (S$1M for each additional outlet)
  • S$100,000 banker's guarantee per location
  • Character and fitness requirements for applicants
  • Interest rates capped at 1.5% per month by law
  • Only ~242 registered pawnshops across Singapore

These regulatory requirements create moderate barriers to entry but are not insurmountable for well-capitalized entrants.

Scale Advantages:

  • Largest loan balance per outlet among listed peers
  • Network of 47 outlets in Singapore provides convenience advantage
  • Multi-outlet redemption flexibility
  • Decades of expertise in gold/jewellery valuation

Moat Limitations

  1. Commodity-like service: Pawnbroking is fundamentally a commoditized service. Interest rates are capped by law, so ValueMax cannot differentiate on pricing.
  2. Low switching costs: Customers can walk to any pawnshop. There is no lock-in effect beyond convenience and trust.
  3. Gold price dependency: The business model is heavily correlated with gold prices (0.8 correlation to stock price, 0.9 to loan book). ValueMax is more a "gold price proxy" than a true compounder.
  4. Fintech disruption: Online lending platforms and digital gold trading could erode the pawnbroking model over time, though Singapore's regulatory framework provides some protection.

Moat Durability Assessment

The moat is NARROW. The regulatory barriers and brand trust provide some protection, but the fundamental service is commoditized, switching costs are low, and the business is overwhelmingly driven by gold price cycles rather than intrinsic competitive advantages.

3. Financial Fortress Assessment

Income Statement Trends (SGD millions)

Metric FY2020 FY2021 FY2022 FY2023 FY2024
Revenue 276.1 275.5 287.1 331.0 456.2
Operating Income 36.2 47.0 51.7 64.3 89.8
Net Income 33.9 41.5 44.4 52.9 82.8
EPS (SGD) 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.07 0.10

Revenue has compounded at ~13% annually over five years, while net income has grown at ~25% CAGR -- an impressive track record. However, several factors temper the headline numbers:

Warning Sign 1: EPS Growth Trails Net Income Growth Despite net income growing 144% from FY2020 to FY2024, EPS only grew from SGD 0.06 to SGD 0.10 (~67%). The reason: shares outstanding ballooned from 565M to 847M (a 50% increase) through scrip dividend schemes and bonus issues. This dilution is a significant drag on per-share compounding.

Warning Sign 2: Persistently Negative Free Cash Flow

Metric FY2020 FY2021 FY2022 FY2023 FY2024
Operating CF 13.0 -154.8 -164.1 3.5 -56.3
Free Cash Flow 12.5 -157.1 -164.6 -1.7 -67.7

ValueMax has generated cumulative FCF of negative S$378M over five years, despite cumulative net income of S$255M. The divergence between reported earnings and cash generation is explained by the rapid expansion of its loan book -- loans receivable grow as gold prices rise and more customers pawn items at higher valuations. This growth is funded by borrowings, not retained earnings.

Warning Sign 3: Rising Debt Levels Total debt has more than doubled from S$319M (FY2020) to S$701M (FY2024), with net debt rising from S$307M to S$684M. The debt-to-equity ratio of 1.37x is high for a financial services company. While the debt funds income-producing assets (loans), a sharp decline in gold prices could impair collateral values and create significant writedowns.

Balance Sheet Quality

Metric FY2020 FY2021 FY2022 FY2023 FY2024
Total Assets 591.1 799.1 1,010.4 1,076.6 1,247.1
Shareholders' Equity 255.0 327.4 369.0 428.9 517.8
Total Debt 319.4 453.6 621.8 624.8 701.0
Book Value/Share 0.43 0.46 0.50 0.53 0.59

Book value per share has grown from SGD 0.43 to SGD 0.59 -- a 37% increase over five years (6.5% CAGR). This is respectable but not exceptional, especially considering the dilution. Equity has doubled, but so have shares outstanding, partially offsetting the gain for existing shareholders.

Dividend Analysis

Year Dividend/Share Payout Ratio Yield (at current price)
FY2020 SGD 0.018 ~30% 1.5%
FY2021 SGD 0.019 ~30% 1.6%
FY2022 SGD 0.020 ~31% 1.6%
FY2023 SGD 0.022 ~31% 1.8%
FY2024 SGD 0.027 ~26% 2.2%

Dividend growth has been steady but modest at ~10% CAGR. The payout ratio is conservative at ~26-31%, though the scrip dividend option means many shareholders receive shares rather than cash, further diluting per-share value.

Financial Fortress Rating: MODERATE

The company is profitable with growing equity, but the high leverage, persistent negative FCF, and dependence on debt funding for loan book growth create vulnerability. In a scenario where gold prices decline sharply, collateral values would fall, loan demand would decrease, and ValueMax could face a double hit of lower earnings and potential writedowns -- all while servicing S$700M+ in debt.

4. Risk Assessment

Primary Risk: Gold Price Dependency

ValueMax's earnings are highly correlated to gold prices (0.8 correlation to share price, 0.96 to retail/trading revenue). The company is essentially a leveraged play on gold. If gold prices mean-revert from current all-time highs:

  • Retail/trading revenue (75% of total) would decline
  • Collateral values on existing loans would fall
  • New loan origination would slow
  • The double benefit of rising gold on both loan books and inventory would reverse

Gold has risen from ~USD 1,800/oz in early 2023 to ~USD 2,900/oz in early 2026 -- a 61% increase. ValueMax's share price has risen ~149% in the past year, demonstrating the leveraged exposure. The reverse would be equally dramatic.

Secondary Risk: Balance Sheet Leverage

With total debt of S$701M against equity of S$518M (1.37x D/E), ValueMax is materially leveraged. For a company that has generated negative cumulative FCF over five years, this leverage is funded entirely by rolling over short-term borrowings. In a credit crunch or rate spike, refinancing risk is real.

Other Risks

  • Share dilution: 67% increase in shares outstanding over 5 years via scrip dividends and bonus issues
  • Regulatory risk: Changes to pawnbroking regulations (interest rate caps, capital requirements)
  • Key person risk: Family-controlled business with 59% ownership by Yeah Holdings
  • Cyclicality: Pawnbroking demand is counter-cyclical (rises in recessions) but gold trading is pro-cyclical with gold prices
  • Altman Z-Score of 1.51: Falls in the "grey zone" (between 1.1 and 2.6), indicating moderate bankruptcy risk
  • Fintech disruption: Digital lending platforms could slowly erode traditional pawnbroking volumes

5. Valuation Analysis

Current Valuation Multiples

Metric Value Historical Context
P/E (TTM) 12.1x At high end of historical range (7-13x)
P/B 2.04x Near historical high
EV/EBITDA 15.7x Elevated due to high enterprise value from debt
Dividend Yield 2.2% Below historical average (~4%)
FCF Yield Negative Persistently negative FCF

Intrinsic Value Estimation

Method 1: Earnings-Based Valuation

Normalized earnings (adjusting for one-time Well Chip gain of S$10.1M in FY2024): ~S$73M Appropriate P/E for a leveraged, gold-dependent financial business: 8-10x Fair value range: S$73M x 8-10x = S$584M - S$730M Per share (943.5M shares): SGD 0.62 - SGD 0.77

Method 2: Book Value-Based Valuation

Book value per share: SGD 0.59 ROE of 18.7% justifies premium to book, but leverage and dilution are concerns. Appropriate P/B: 1.3-1.5x Fair value range: SGD 0.77 - SGD 0.89

Method 3: Peer Comparison

Singapore-listed pawnbroking peers historically trade at 7-12x earnings. ValueMax, as the market leader with highest ROE, deserves the upper end of this range. At 10x normalized earnings: SGD 0.77 per share At 12x peak earnings: SGD 1.05 per share

Fair Value Assessment

Method Low High
Earnings-based SGD 0.62 SGD 0.77
Book value-based SGD 0.77 SGD 0.89
Peer comparison SGD 0.77 SGD 1.05
Composite Fair Value SGD 0.72 SGD 0.90

At the current price of SGD 1.22, ValueMax appears overvalued by 36-69% relative to fair value estimates. The stock is pricing in continued record gold prices and earnings growth, with no margin of safety.

6. Entry Price Analysis

Level Price P/E (Normalized) Implied Yield Rationale
Strong Buy SGD 0.65 7x 4.2% Deep value; prices in gold correction
Accumulate SGD 0.80 8.5x 3.4% Fair value with modest margin of safety
Fair Value SGD 0.85 9x 3.2% Appropriate for quality/risk profile
Current SGD 1.22 12.1x 2.2% Prices in peak cycle earnings

The current gap from Accumulate price is -34.4%, meaning the stock would need to decline by about a third to reach attractive entry levels.

7. Management Assessment

Owner-Operator Model

ValueMax is a family-controlled business, which can be both an advantage and a risk.

Yeah Hiang Nam (Founder, Executive Chairman):

  • Over 50 years in gold/jewellery industry, 30+ years in pawnbroking
  • Transformed Singapore's pawnbroking industry from stigmatized to professional
  • Public Service Medal recipient (2016), EY Entrepreneur of the Year (2019)
  • Controls ~59% of company through Yeah Holdings Pte. Ltd.

Yeah Chia Kai (CEO, son):

  • MBA from Columbia/London Business School
  • Joined 2004, briefly left to found software company, returned 2007
  • Responsible for strategy and business development

Yeah Lee Ching (MD Retail & Trading, daughter):

  • MBA from NUS, GIA Gemologist certification
  • 20+ years in jewellery/gemstones industry

Capital Allocation Assessment: C+

Positives:

  • Consistent dividend growth (10% CAGR over 5 years)
  • Strategic acquisitions (Heng Heng, Ban Fook pawnshops in 2025)
  • Expansion of outlet network (from ~30 to 47 in Singapore)

Negatives:

  • Persistent share dilution (50%+ over 5 years via scrip dividends, bonus issues)
  • Heavy reliance on debt funding for growth (debt more than doubled)
  • Negative FCF in 4 of 5 years despite record profitability
  • Capital-intensive growth strategy funded by leverage rather than retained earnings
  • IPO-era shareholders have seen their ownership significantly diluted

The scrip dividend scheme is particularly concerning. While it conserves cash, it systematically dilutes existing shareholders who opt for cash dividends. This is a form of capital allocation that transfers value from non-participating shareholders to the company.

8. Catalyst Assessment

Positive Catalysts

  • Continued gold price appreciation (geopolitical tensions, central bank buying, de-dollarization)
  • Expansion of moneylending and property financing segments (higher-margin businesses)
  • Accretive pawnshop acquisitions (Heng Heng, Ban Fook completed in March 2025)
  • Counter-cyclical demand if Singapore enters economic downturn
  • Potential for special dividends or increased payout if gold remains elevated

Negative Catalysts

  • Gold price correction from all-time highs (most significant risk)
  • Rising interest rates increasing funding costs on S$701M debt
  • Regulatory tightening on pawnbroking or moneylending
  • Economic recovery reducing pawnbroking demand
  • Continued share dilution eroding per-share value

9. H1 2025 Results Analysis (Most Recent)

ValueMax reported strong H1 2025 results, driven by record gold prices:

Metric H1 2025 H1 2024 Change
Revenue S$268.3M S$229.8M +16.8%
Gross Profit S$81.1M S$63.5M +27.7%
Gross Margin 30.2% 27.6% +260bps
Net Profit S$48.8M S$35.9M +35.7%

Key highlights:

  • Retail and trading of jewellery/gold: S$204.8M revenue (+17.5% YoY)
  • Pawnbroking revenue: +20.2% YoY
  • Moneylending revenue: +10.7% YoY
  • Acquisition of Heng Heng and Ban Fook pawnshops contributed S$30.4M in revenue
  • Interim dividend of 1.2 cents per share declared
  • Total assets reached S$1.37 billion

The results were strong but heavily gold-driven. Stripping out the acquisition contribution (S$30.4M), organic revenue growth was closer to ~4%, which is more representative of the underlying business trajectory.

10. Investment Thesis

ValueMax Group is a well-run, family-controlled pawnbroking chain with a strong market position in Singapore. The business has delivered impressive headline growth, with revenue and net income compounding at 13% and 25% CAGR respectively over five years. Management has transformed the pawnbroking industry in Singapore, building a trusted brand with nearly 50 outlets.

However, the investment case has significant structural weaknesses that the current euphoric gold price environment is masking:

  1. ValueMax is not a compounder -- it is a leveraged gold proxy. With a 0.8 correlation to gold prices and 0.96 correlation to retail/trading revenue, the company's fortunes rise and fall with the gold price. At current all-time highs, the business looks exceptional. If gold reverts to USD 2,000/oz, the picture would be starkly different.

  2. Persistent negative free cash flow means the business cannot fund its own growth. It borrows to grow its loan book, which creates vulnerability to credit cycles and rising interest rates.

  3. Systematic share dilution has eroded per-share value growth. Net income grew 144% over five years, but EPS grew only 67%. Shareholders who opt for cash dividends are being diluted by those who take scrip.

  4. The moat is narrow. Pawnbroking is a regulated but commoditized service. Interest rates are capped by law. Switching costs are minimal. The main barriers to entry are capital requirements and brand trust -- real but not durable enough to justify premium multiples.

At SGD 1.22 (12.1x earnings, 2.04x book), the stock is priced for continued peak-cycle performance with no margin of safety. The patient value investor should wait for a gold price correction or market selloff to create an entry point at SGD 0.80 or below, where the risk/reward becomes favorable.

Disclaimer: This analysis is for educational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. The author does not hold a position in T6I.