TECK - Teck Resources Ltd Class B
Executive Summary
3-Sentence Investment Thesis
Teck Resources is transforming from a diversified miner into a pure-play copper company through its 2024 steelmaking coal divestiture ($8.6B) and pending Anglo American merger, which will create a global top-5 copper producer with 1.2M tons annual production. The QB2 copper mine ramp-up challenges have depressed current profitability (ROE 1.6%) and created investor frustration, but the asset base remains world-class with 10 billion tons of reserves/resources at QB alone. David Einhorn's 3.8% position and the Anglo merger (37.6% Teck ownership of combined entity) provide validation, but current P/E of 32x on depressed earnings and operational execution risk require patience for a better entry.
Key Metrics Dashboard
| Metric | Value | Assessment |
|---|---|---|
| Current Price | $53.76 | 8% below 52-week high |
| Market Cap | $26.3B | Large-cap miner |
| P/E (TTM) | 32.2x | Expensive on depressed earnings |
| P/B | 1.55x | Reasonable for resource base |
| EV/EBITDA | 11.65x | In line with peers |
| ROE (Latest) | 1.6% | FAILS Buffett 15% test |
| ROE (5yr Avg) | 6.3% | Cyclical business |
| Net Debt/EBITDA | ~3.0x | Elevated but manageable |
| Dividend Yield | 0.86% | Modest income |
| Beta | 1.54 | High volatility |
Recommendation
| VERDICT | WAIT - Quality copper exposure via merger catalyst, but no margin of safety at current price |
| Strong Buy Price | $35 (35% below current) |
| Accumulate Price | $42 (22% below current) |
| Fair Value Estimate | $50-55 |
| Quality Grade | B+ |
| Tier | T2 Resilient |
Phase 0: Opportunity Identification (Klarman Framework)
Why Does This Opportunity Exist?
QB2 Execution Frustration: The flagship Quebrada Blanca 2 copper mine has faced persistent tailings management facility (TMF) issues, causing repeated guidance cuts (original 270K tons -> 190K tons for 2025). Investors have lost patience with management credibility on timelines.
Merger Arbitrage Complexity: The Anglo American merger creates uncertainty about ultimate structure, regulatory approvals, and synergy realization. Some investors prefer to wait for deal closure.
Commodity Cyclicality: Copper prices are volatile, and Teck's earnings swing dramatically with commodity cycles (2022 net margin 19.2% vs 2024 net margin 4.5%).
Transition Period Earnings: The steelmaking coal sale (2024) and QB2 ramp-up costs create abnormally depressed current earnings, making traditional valuation metrics misleading.
Is This a Permanent or Temporary Problem?
TEMPORARY - The QB2 issues are engineering/construction challenges, not geological or structural business problems. Management expects TMF constraints to end by 2027. The merger provides a catalyst for value realization.
Phase 1: Risk Analysis (Munger Inversion)
"How Could This Investment Lose 50%+ Permanently?"
Copper Price Collapse: A severe global recession dropping copper below $3/lb for extended period would devastate Teck's economics. QB2 cash costs of ~$2.20/lb provide limited cushion.
QB2 Permanent Impairment: If TMF issues prove unsolvable or new geological/geotechnical problems emerge, the $8B+ QB2 investment could be written down significantly.
Anglo Merger Failure: Regulatory rejection (especially Chile or UK) would eliminate the synergy catalyst and potentially leave Teck as a smaller, less competitive standalone entity.
China Demand Destruction: 57% of copper demand is China-linked. A China property collapse or trade decoupling could structurally lower copper demand.
Nationalization/Taxation: Chile (QB2 location) has politically volatile mining policies. Royalty increases or adverse regulation could impair asset values.
Risk Quantification
| Risk Event | Probability | Impact | Expected Loss |
|---|---|---|---|
| Copper price collapse (<$3/lb, 2+ years) | 15% | -50% | -7.5% |
| QB2 permanent impairment | 10% | -40% | -4.0% |
| Anglo merger failure | 15% | -25% | -3.75% |
| Chile nationalization/adverse regulation | 5% | -35% | -1.75% |
| China demand destruction | 10% | -40% | -4.0% |
| TOTAL EXPECTED DOWNSIDE | -21% |
Bear Case Summary (3 Sentences)
Teck is trading at 32x depressed earnings for a business with 1.6% ROE that has failed to execute on its flagship $8B copper project. The Anglo merger adds execution risk and may not close, while copper prices face headwinds from China property weakness and potential global recession. Management has repeatedly missed QB2 guidance, eroding credibility and suggesting structural operational issues rather than temporary challenges.
Inversion Questions
Q: What would make me sell immediately (non-price triggers)?
- Anglo merger terminated
- QB2 declared permanently impaired
- Chile implements 50%+ royalty regime
- CEO resignation during ramp-up
- Copper price sustained below $3/lb for 6+ months
Q: Can I state the bear case better than the bears? Yes - the bear case is legitimate. Teck's ROE has been structurally below cost of capital for most of its history, and the company is betting everything on copper at a time when prices are elevated. However, the merger addresses scale concerns and the asset base is genuinely world-class.
Phase 2: Financial Analysis
Historical Performance (5-Year Summary)
| Year | Revenue ($B) | Op Margin | Net Margin | ROE | FCF ($B) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2020 | 8.95 | -10.2% | -9.7% | -4.3% | -2.06 |
| 2021 | 12.77 | 39.0% | 22.5% | 12.5% | 0.03 |
| 2022 | 17.32 | 40.3% | 19.2% | 13.0% | 2.52 |
| 2023 | 6.48 | 3.4% | 37.2% | 8.9% | -0.26 |
| 2024 | 9.06 | -0.1% | 4.5% | 1.6% | 0.15 |
Key Observations:
- Revenue highly cyclical (ranged $6.5B to $17.3B)
- Operating margins swing from -10% to +40%
- 5-year average ROE of 6.3% fails Buffett 15% test
- FCF inconsistent due to massive QB2 CapEx ($4-5B annually in 2022-2023)
Balance Sheet Strength
| Metric | 2024 | Assessment |
|---|---|---|
| Total Assets | $47.0B | Substantial resource base |
| Total Equity | $26.1B | Book value = $50/share |
| Cash | $7.6B | Strong post-coal-sale |
| Total Debt | $10.0B | Manageable |
| Net Debt | $2.4B | Conservative leverage |
| D/E Ratio | 0.76 | Acceptable |
DuPont ROE Decomposition (2024)
ROE = Net Margin × Asset Turnover × Equity Multiplier
1.6% = 4.5% × 0.19 × 1.80
The low ROE is driven by:
- Depressed net margins (QB2 costs, coal business sold)
- Low asset turnover (massive capital invested in QB2 not yet producing)
Owner Earnings Calculation
Owner Earnings (2024) = Net Income + D&A - Maintenance CapEx
= $406M + $1,726M - ~$1,200M
= ~$932M
Per Share (481M shares) = $1.94
At 15x multiple = $29/share (well below current price)
At 20x multiple = $39/share (still below current)
Note: Current earnings are not normalized. At full QB2 production (2027+), owner earnings could be $2-3B annually.
Normalized Earnings Power (2027E Estimate)
Assuming:
- QB2 at 270K tons copper @ $2/lb cash cost
- Highland Valley, Antamina, Carmen de Andacollo stable
- Zinc segment contribution
- Copper price $4.25/lb average
QB2 EBITDA: 270K tons × 2000 lbs × $2.25 margin = $1.22B
Other Copper: ~$1.5B
Zinc: ~$0.5B
Corporate/Other: -$0.4B
---
Normalized EBITDA: ~$2.8B (Teck standalone)
With Anglo merger synergies ($800M+): Could exceed $4B+
Valuation Analysis
| Method | Value/Share | vs Current ($53.76) |
|---|---|---|
| Book Value | $50.00 | -7% |
| Current Owner Earnings (10x) | $19.40 | -64% |
| Current Owner Earnings (15x) | $29.10 | -46% |
| Normalized Owner Earnings (15x) | $58-65 | +8-21% |
| EV/EBITDA (8x on normalized) | $55-60 | +2-12% |
| Anglo merger implied | $47-55 | -12% to +2% |
Graham Number:
Graham Number = sqrt(22.5 × EPS × BVPS)
= sqrt(22.5 × $1.67 × $50)
= sqrt($1,879)
= $43.35
Conclusion: At $53.76, Teck is trading above Graham Number ($43) and near the upper end of fair value estimates. There is limited margin of safety.
Phase 3: Moat Analysis
Moat Sources
| Moat Type | Present? | Strength | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cost Advantage | Yes | MODERATE | QB2 low strip ratio, Pilbara-quality ore body |
| Scale | Yes | NARROW (growing) | 480K tons copper currently, 1.2M+ post-merger |
| Asset Irreplaceability | Yes | STRONG | 10B tons QB reserves, 25+ year mine life |
| Network Effects | No | - | Commodity business |
| Switching Costs | No | - | Copper is fungible |
| Regulatory | Partial | MODERATE | Long-term permits, but regulatory risk too |
Moat Width: NARROW (widening to MODERATE post-merger)
Supporting Evidence:
- QB2 has one of the world's largest undeveloped copper resources
- Tax stability agreement in Chile through 2037
- 2027 QB/Collahuasi adjacency synergies ($1.4B annual EBITDA potential)
- Post-merger scale will be #5 global copper
Erosion Forces:
- Chile political risk (royalty increases)
- New copper supply coming (Kamoa-Kakula, Resolution)
- Technological substitution (aluminum in some applications)
- Chinese copper production increasing
Moat Durability: 10-15 years
The QB2 ore body and reserve base provide durable competitive advantage, but copper mining does not have true moats - it's a cost curve business where the lowest-cost producers win.
Phase 4: Management & Decision Synthesis
Management Assessment
CEO: Jonathan Price (since 2022)
- Former CFO, strong financial background
- Navigated steelmaking coal sale successfully
- Mixed operational execution at QB2
Capital Allocation Track Record:
- $8.6B coal sale at good price (5x EBITDA)
- $1.8B returned to shareholders (2024)
- $3.25B buyback program (70% executed)
- Highland Valley MLE approved (C$2.1-2.4B)
Insider Ownership: 2.3% (modest, not exceptional)
Compensation: Reasonable relative to peers
Superinvestor Validation
David Einhorn (Greenlight Capital): 3.8% position
- Einhorn is known for deep value, contrarian positions
- His track record is strong on cyclical/special situation investments
- Provides validation of the copper transition thesis
Catalyst Assessment
| Catalyst | Timeline | Probability | Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| Anglo merger close | H1-H2 2026 | 85% | +15-20% |
| QB2 reaches steady state | Q4 2026-2027 | 70% | +10-15% |
| QB/Collahuasi synergies realized | 2027-2028 | 60% | +5-10% |
| Copper price sustained >$4.50/lb | Uncertain | 40% | +20-30% |
Position Sizing Formula
Base Allocation: 3%
× MOS Adjustment (0% MOS / 20% target): 0.5x
× Quality Score (B+ = 75/100): 0.75x
× (1 - Risk Score 0.21): 0.79x
× Catalyst Multiplier (strong catalyst): 1.2x
Position Size = 3% × 0.5 × 0.75 × 0.79 × 1.2 = 1.1%
Recommendation: At current prices, no position. Wait for 20%+ pullback.
Expected Return Probability Tree
| Scenario | Probability | Return | Weighted |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bull (merger + copper rally) | 20% | +60% | +12% |
| Base (merger closes, QB2 normalizes) | 45% | +20% | +9% |
| Bear (execution issues persist) | 25% | -15% | -3.75% |
| Disaster (merger fails, copper crash) | 10% | -45% | -4.5% |
| Expected Return | 100% | +12.75% |
Monitoring Triggers
| Metric | Current | Threshold | Action |
|---|---|---|---|
| QB2 quarterly production | 55K tons | <40K tons | Reassess thesis |
| Copper price | ~$4.25/lb | <$3.50/lb | Increase caution |
| Anglo merger status | Approved by shareholders | Regulatory rejection | Exit immediately |
| Net debt/EBITDA | ~3x | >4x | Pause accumulation |
Explicit Sell Triggers
- Thesis Break: Anglo merger terminated or QB2 declared permanently impaired
- Moat Erosion: Chile implements confiscatory taxation (>50% effective rate)
- Management Failure: CEO departure during critical transition period
- Valuation: Price exceeds $80 (50%+ above normalized fair value)
Conclusion
Final Verdict: WAIT
Teck Resources represents a compelling copper exposure vehicle with world-class assets, superinvestor validation, and a transformative merger catalyst. However, the current valuation of 32x depressed earnings and 1.55x book value provides insufficient margin of safety for a business that:
- Has failed Buffett's ROE test for most of its history
- Faces significant execution risk at QB2
- Operates in a cyclical commodity business
Entry Strategy:
- Strong Buy: $35 (35% pullback, ~0.7x book value)
- Accumulate: $42 (22% pullback, Graham Number area)
- Watch List: Current price of $53.76
The Anglo merger is likely to close (85% probability), which would create a more investable global copper champion. However, patient investors should wait for either:
- A copper price pullback that drags shares lower
- Another QB2 disappointment creating a buying opportunity
- Broader market correction
David Einhorn's 3.8% position validates the copper transition thesis, but even great investors time entries carefully. At current prices, the risk/reward is unfavorable.
Sources
- AlphaVantage MCP: Company Overview, Financial Statements, Earnings Transcripts (Q4 2024, Q1-Q3 2025)
- Historical Prices: AlphaVantage TIME_SERIES_DAILY_ADJUSTED
- Anglo American merger press releases (Sept-Dec 2025)
- Teck Resources investor presentations and news releases
Analysis completed with AI assistance. All conclusions represent independent first-principles analysis, not reliance on analyst reports or price targets.